A judge has denied a defense attempt to recuse the U.S. attorney’s office from prosecuting a cardiologist accused of collecting millions in false insurance billings and his trial has begun.
Thomas Kenny, who represents Samirkumar Shah, said in a motion filed Monday that government lawyers should be recused because Dr. Shah’s previous lawyer was Tina Miller, now chief of the criminal division for U.S. Attorney Scott Brady.
He said her presence as a leader of the prosecution staff is a conflict of interest, but U.S. District Judge David Cercone denied the motion from the bench and the first testimony began Tuesday afternoon.
Dr. Shah, who lives in Kittanning and has 11 offices across the region, is charged with submitting bills for angina treatments administered to patients who did not have angina.
He is also accused of double-billing for those treatments and ripping off Medicare, Medicaid and private insurance companies dating to 2008.
In her opening statement, Assistant U.S. Attorney Nicole Vasquez Schmitt said the government will prove that Dr. Shah falsely diagnosed patients with angina, a heart condition, so he could treat them with external counter-pulsation therapy, or ECP. The treatment is legitimate and covered by insurance, but only for people with disabling angina.
Read More
She said his patients didn’t have the condition, yet he told insurance they did so he could bill for use of his ECP beds at $200 a session.
Ms. Schmitt said that the patients in many cases were in good physical shape, yet the doctor diagnosed them with angina anyway, including a healthy undercover agent who posed as a potential patient in 2013.
She said he set up ECP beds in his various offices and was not present when the treatments were administered as required by insurance.
Treatments began as early as 5 a.m. in some locations and lasted into the evening. In one day alone, she said, he billed for 77 ECP treatments and could not have possibly been in his far-flung offices for that many.
“That,” she told the jury, “is fraud.”
Among the government witnesses will be former patients who in many cases never met the doctor and office staffers who said he was not around — and sometimes out of the state — when the treatments were done, Ms. Schmitt said.
Dr. Shah’s lawyer, Mr. Kenny, disputed the government’s portrayal of his client as a crook and described the doctor as the “little guy” being picked on by giant insurance conglomerates.
He said Dr. Shah was honoring his oath as a doctor to help patients with his ECP treatments and denied the prosecution’s contention that he falsely diagnosed anyone.
He said only one person in the courtroom is qualified to diagnose angina, and that’s Dr. Shah.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.