A cardiologist with several offices in Allegheny County who is set for trial next week on fraud charges in connection with what he called "fountain of youth" angina treatments has lost a last-ditch effort to have his statements to agents and a prosecutor tossed out of court.

U.S. District Judge David Cercone on Friday ruled against a suppression motion brought by Samirkumar Shah, saying his statements were voluntary and no one violated his due process rights.

Dr. Shah lives in Kittanning and had 11 offices in Fox Chapel, Wexford, Penn Hills and elsewhere across the region. He is accused of submitting some $2.5 million in false billings to insurance for angina treatments that patients didn't need using a non-invasive procedure called external counter pulsation therapy, or CPT, he said would increase blood flow through the use of pressure cuffs.

Prosecutors say Dr. Shah advertised his therapy in newspapers as a cure-all, then recruited patients who didn't have angina to undergo the procedure by poorly trained staffers in his various offices.

Advertise with us

They said he wasn't present in his office when it was administered and then sent in bills to Medicare, Medicaid and private insurance to pay for it.

Dr. Shah was indicted in 2016 after an investigation by the FBI and state attorney general's office.

Former Assistant U.S. Attorney Nelson Cohen, who has since retired, said in prior court filings that Dr. Shah had invested $1 million in CPT beds and needed to recoup that money.

"The frauds at issue were motivated purely by money without any concern for the patients whose insurers were defrauded," he said.

In the suppression motion, Dr. Shah and his lawyer, Thomas Kenny, argued that Dr. Shah thought he was in custody when agents interviewed him at his Fox Chapel office in December 2013 and again when he was questioned at the U.S. attorney's office in Pittsburgh two months later.

Advertise with us

He and Mr. Kenny said he was never read his Miranda rights and so his statements should be thrown out. They also argued that because he was born in India, a country without U.S. constitutional protections, he didn't feel he was free to leave what he described as "interrogation."

Prosecutors countered that Dr. Shah was never in custody during the interviews and was told he was free to leave.

Both times he agreed to be interviewed, said Eric Olshan and Nicole Schmitt, assistant U.S. attorneys, and no one coerced him.

Although Dr. Shah claimed that the second interview occurred in a locked room at the U.S. attorney's office, prosecutors said the room was never locked and Dr. Shah could have left.

During the first interview, an FBI agent and a state attorney general's agent told him he could leave if wanted to, the prosecutors said. They said he even went out to his car to get some records, proving he wasn't in custody.

Advertise with us

"Throughout the interaction the defendant repeatedly indicated that he wanted to cooperate with law enforcement and would help in any way he could," the prosecutors said. "At the completion of the interview, the agents told the defendant that it was up to him whether to leave or stay on the premises."

Dr. Shah later agreed to come to the U.S. attorney's office, the prosecutors said, to meet again with the agents and Mr. Cohen.

Dr. Shah said he was "summoned" to come to the office, but the prosecution said he was invited and also told that he could bring a lawyer if he chose.

They said he was also told he didn't have to answer any questions.

At one point, Mr. Cohen advised him to get a lawyer who understood federal criminal law, according to the government, because he was going to be charged with felony healthcare fraud.

Advertise with us

Judge Cercone sided with the government after a hearing Friday. The case is set for trial starting Monday.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.