A former gymnastics coach whose sex assault convictions were overturned last year when an appeals court ruled that an Allegheny County judge erred in how she handled the case made a plea deal Monday and received a significantly less severe sentence.
Keith R. Callen, 48, of Sarver, pleaded guilty before Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Jill E. Rangos to one count each of aggravated indecent assault, sexual assault by a sports official, unlawful contact and corruption of minors.
In exchange for the plea, the district attorney’s office agreed to a sentence of two to four years in state prison, five years of probation and a lifetime registration as a sex offender.
In May 2017, the judge who handled the initial trial, Donna Jo McDaniel, sentenced Callen to 13 to 26 years in prison. But that sentence took into account charges that Callen sexually assaulted girls in both Allegheny and Butler counties.
Mike Manko, spokesman for the DA’s office, said that Monday’s plea deal pertained only to crimes in Allegheny County.
The charges related to a girl who police said Callen abused from 2010 through 2015 when he was coaching gymnastics at Jewart’s Gymnastics in Hampton and at Trinity Gymnastics in West Deer — both in Allegheny County.
Read More
“In any case involving the sexual assault of a child, the welfare and protection of the victim is paramount. Today’s plea was an appropriate resolution to this case,” Mr. Manko said, adding that the DA’s office would prefer not to have victims testify if they don’t have to.
After Callen was arrested in April 2016, two additional victims reported to police that he had abused them when they were young — one between the ages of 5 and 9, the other between 4 and 8 — at his home in Butler County from 1998 and 2002. As well, the victim in the Allegheny County case also told police that Callen abused her at Elite Athletic Center in Butler County.
Online court records show a case against Callen is pending in Butler County and trial is scheduled for Wednesday on charges of aggravated indecent assault, endangering the welfare of children and other counts related to child sexual assault.
Whether the cases should have been combined at trial was the central issue that led Superior Court to reverse Callen’s conviction and remand the cases for new trials.
Ms. McDaniel, a veteran judge who retired Jan. 31, had previously stirred controversy over what was considered by some to be unduly harsh punishments for sex offenders. She was removed by state Superior Court from presiding over cases involving three sex offenders.
In the Callen case, Superior Court ruled that Ms. McDaniel erred in allowing one set of charges to be tried in Allegheny County when the underlying crimes occurred in Butler.
Because the two cases were tried together — and the conduct in each set of allegations was significantly different — both convictions had to be reversed and the sentences vacated, wrote Superior Court Judge Judith Olson.
Both cases were filed in Allegheny County.
Callen’s defense attorney argued to then-Judge McDaniel that the case involving the two younger victims should be moved to Butler County, where the underlying allegations were said to have occurred.
The prosecution, however, said during oral argument that they should remain in Allegheny County “because these sexual assaults have taken place over a length of time and this conduct is a course of conduct [and because] the district attorney’s offices [of Allegheny County and Butler County] consulted with each other and it was determined that Allegheny County would prosecute as to all victims here.”
Judge McDaniel agreed with the prosecution and allowed the cases to proceed. The two cases were joined and went to trial together in March 2017.
A jury found Callen guilty on all counts, and he was ordered to serve 13 to 26 years in prison.
Although the three-judge Superior Court panel wrote in its opinion that the evidence presented against Callen at trial was sufficient to warrant conviction on both cases, Judge McDaniel erred in allowing the case against the two youngest victims to be heard in Allegheny County.
The victim in the case in which Callen pleaded guilty won a $500,000 civil verdict last month in Allegheny County against Trinity Gymnastics after a jury found it negligent.
The defendant is asking the court to either reverse the verdict and find in favor of Trinity or grant a new trial.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.