The Department of Justice on Monday announced that it has taken over a whistleblower suit filed two years ago against Wheeling Hospital, a Pittsburgh management consultant firm and its CEO, alleging a kickback scheme and illegal payments to doctors to boost revenue.

The suit, in which the U.S. attorney’s office in Pittsburgh intervened under the False Claims Act, names the hospital, R&V Associates and Ronald Violi, the CEO.

The complaint says that Grant Street-based R&V and Mr. Violi, who lives in O’Hara and was formerly CEO at Children’s Hospital in Pittsburgh, violated the Stark Law, which prohibits a hospital from billing Medicare for services referred by doctors who have improper financial relationships with the hospital.

The complaint also says the defendants violated the Anti-Kickback statute, which prohibits payments that are made to “induce referrals of services” covered by Medicare or Medicaid.

Advertise with us

The complaint isn’t new; it was initially filed in Pittsburgh federal court under seal in 2017 by Louis Longo, the previous executive vice president of the hospital.

The case was unsealed in December after DOJ announced that it was joining the suit as a plaintiff.

Now DOJ has taken over the case.

The lawsuit was brought under the whistleblower provisions of the False Claims Act, which allow private parties to sue on behalf of the U.S. The act allows the U.S. to intervene, which is what has now happened.

The U.S. attorney’s office said that Wheeling Hospital’s payments to employed and contracted doctors violated the law because they were based on the volume of doctor referrals rather than patient need and exceeded the market value of their services.

Advertise with us

“Improper financial arrangements between hospitals and physicians can influence the type and amount of health care that is provided,” said Assistant Attorney General Jody Hunt of DOJ’s civil division.

According to the complaint, the hospital, under the direction of R&V and Mr. Violi, entered into unlawful financial arrangements with physicians strictly to bring in more revenue.

In the early 2000s, the hospital was suffering financially, having lost more than $55 million from 1998 to 2005.

In 2006, Wheeling entered into a management contract with R&V to improve its financial performance.

Within five years, according to the suit, the hospital made a profit of nearly $90 million. The hospital paid R&V and Mr. Violi millions for their services, the suit says, and the contract is still in place.

Advertise with us

R&V’s approach was to hire a large number of doctors to capture their patient referrals and dominate the Ohio Valley market. According to the complaint, they accomplished that by paying the doctors what amount to kickbacks.

The suit says that Mr. Violi and R&V were focused heavily on revenue in discussions regarding compensation for doctors.

In one 2008 memo regarding pay for surgeon Ahmad Rahbar, for example, hospital CFO Jim Murdy wrote “we should keep in mind that Rahbar is a man we need to keep happy. In FY07 he generated over $11 million in revenues for us,” according to the complaint.

In a 2012 memo, COO Scott McKeets wrote with respect to reducing pay for a doctor, gynecologist Chandra Swamy, “I would not recommend doing so anyway as we would not want to endanger the significant downstream revenue that she produces for Wheeling Hospital,” the complaint says.

The suit cites numerous other examples.

Advertise with us

“As a result, since at least 2007, defendants knowingly submitted and caused to be submitted thousands of false claims to the United States, which resulted in millions of dollars of reimbursement to Wheeling Hospital by the Medicare program for claims that were ineligible for payment because of Defendants’ unlawful conduct,” the suit says.

The law requires that compensation paid to doctors by hospitals excludes the “volume and value” of patient referrals by those doctors. The idea is to make sure doctors provide treatment based on patient need rather than profit.

But the complaint says the hospital’s goal was to gain “monopolistic power” in the Ohio Valley, with some doctors paid more than $1 million a year.

“Medicare and Medicaid beneficiaries trust that their healthcare providers will make decisions based on sound medical judgment,” said U.S. Attorney Scott W. Brady. “Our office will take decisive action against any medical providers who betray that trust and make medical decisions based on their own financial interests.”