A former Pittsburgh police sergeant convicted in federal court of beating up a drunk teen outside of Heinz Field in 2015 has lost his appeal.

The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals on Friday ruled against Stephen Matakovich, who is serving 27 months at a federal prison in North Carolina.

Matakovich was convicted of using excessive force in assaulting Gabriel Despres, then 19, on Nov. 28, 2015, during high school playoffs at the stadium.

The jury acquitted him of a second count of falsifying a report after the incident.

Advertise with us

Matakovich had argued at trial and again before the appellate court that the force he used was not excessive. At trial he and his lawyer had insisted that he shoved and then punched Mr. Despres because he thought that Mr. Despres was going to attack him.

The jury sided with the prosecution in deciding that Mr. Despres, while drunk and uncooperative, posed no threat.

In his appeal, Matakovich said U.S. District Judge Cathy Bissoon was wrong to deny his motion for judgment of acquittal because of a lack of evidence supporting the excessive force charge.

But a three-judge panel rejected all of his reasons.

"None of these arguments are persuasive, given the overwhelming amount of corroborated evidence," wrote Judge Richard Nygaard.

Advertise with us

Matakovich argued that the U.S. attorney's office portrayed him as the aggressor by improperly introducing evidence from nearby witnesses of his temperament that night. He said those descriptions prejudiced the jury against him because as a trained officer only he could see the threat that Mr. Despres presented.

Judge Nygaard, writing for himself and judges Thomas Vanaskie and Kent Jordan, said there are times when an officer's observations trump those of untrained witnesses.

"But the amount of evidence here from persons who were only feet away — corroborated by video — that characterize Despres as non-threatening, confused, and struggling to protect himself from punches is compelling," he wrote. “A reasonable jury could conclude on this record that Matakovich’s perceptions of Despres as a drunk young man who was itching for a fight — justifying his initial use of force — were simply not credible."

The judges said the same is true for Matakovich's claim that he had to punch Mr. Despres repeatedly because he was resisting arrest. A video of the incident shows him shoving Mr. Despres to the ground, shoving him again when he tries to get up and then punching him in the head and body.

"No one interpreted Despres’ response to Matakovich as aggressive," Judge Nygaard wrote.

Advertise with us

Matakovich had also maintained that Judge Bissoon was wrong to refuse his request to admit a post-arrest dash-cam video into evidence that recorded Mr. Despres' comments while being driven from the hospital to jail. In the recording, Mr. Despres said that Matakovich "can't punch" and "wasn't trying to hurt me," according to the defense.

But the circuit judges ruled that all of the witnesses said Mr. Despres didn't have any injuries before the incident and did have them after. Photos also showed injuries, the judges said.

"It is inconceivable, given this evidence, that a video capturing comments by Despres about the event many hours later would convince a jury that he was not injured," Judge Nygaard wrote.

Matakovich is due to be released in a year.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.