Maureen Karr was the fun one.
She made her six siblings and their families laugh at holiday gatherings, took her karaoke machine with her to parties and made beautiful quilts for every baby born into the family.
On Thursday, two of her sisters told Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Anthony M. Mariani that there are no words to describe the pain they still feel nearly four years after their 56-year-old sister was struck in the head, bound and set on fire by her husband in Duquesne.
James Karr, 50, was found guilty by Judge Mariani of second-degree murder, aggravated arson and related counts in July following a non-jury trial.
On Thursday, Karr was ordered to serve life in prison without parole, with a consecutive 11 to 22 years incarceration to follow.
Judge Mariani explained why he did not find Karr guilty of first-degree murder — a premeditated killing — saying that he had a reasonable doubt that the defendant initially went to the home on Friendship Street that early morning of Dec. 30, 2014, with the intention to kill his wife.
Read More
Instead, Judge Mariani said that some evidence suggested Karr went there to try to repair the couple's relationship, but that the situation then turned violent.
Prosecutors said Karr struck his wife in the head before binding her neck, hands and feet together with floral wire. He then poured vodka on her and lit a fire.
"The pouring of alcohol on her demonstrates a total hardness of heart," Judge Mariani said.
Chris Lyon, one of Ms. Karr's sisters, read a statement to the judge during the hearing, telling the court that she knew by the time she got to her sister's smoldering house that morning who was to blame.
"That was the hold he had on her — taking the things she cared about, her house, her dogs," she said.
Ms. Lyon said she is reminded of Ms. Karr's death every day and that she can't bear to remove her sister's number from her cell phone.
"I'm looking forward to the day when we can rejoice in her life," she said.
When given the chance to speak, Karr told the judge he would remain silent, and his attorney, Lisa Middleman, said he planned to appeal over the 13½-hour video recording of her client in an Allegheny County police interrogation room.
Karr's defense attorneys argued that the recording should have been suppressed because Karr repeatedly asked for an attorney before confessing.
However, because Karr knocked on the door of the room to restart conversation with detectives, the statement was permitted in the case.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.