In the days leading up to his protection-from-abuse hearing, James Karr made several updates on his Facebook page about his situation with his estranged wife, Maureen Karr, and hinted at suicide, a criminal complaint revealed.

“Facebook friend it’s no use going to court tomorrow I’m not going to get my wife back so I guess my eyes will take my life now that’s why I’m doing goodbye I hope somebody shows up at my funeral,” he posted on Sunday.

On Tuesday, police said he admitted, he knocked out his 56-year-old wife, bound her with wire and a bungee cord, poured vodka over her body and set it on fire. He then walked out the back door of the home they had shared on Friendship Street in Duquesne.

The fire occurred one day after a court hearing in which Mrs. Karr sought a protection-from-abuse order against Mr. Karr, who she said “was [threatening] to set the house on fire.” The hearing for that order was postponed until Jan. 7 after Mr. Karr suffered a seizure during Monday’s hearing and refused medical treatment.

Advertise with us

Mr. Karr, 46, told detectives Tuesday night that he bound his wife’s hands behind her back with floral wire after she hit her head on a wall, following an argument. He said she came at him with an ax, so he shoved her. He said he attempted to resuscitate her, but she was unresponsive, so he dragged her to the living room and poured vodka on her body, making a trail to the front door. He then lit it on fire.

A supervisor with the Allegheny County medical examiner’s office said Tuesday night that Mrs. Karr died from smoke inhalation and carbon monoxide poisoning. Her death was ruled a homicide. Mr. Karr has been charged with homicide and arson, according to court records.

After Mrs. Karr received a temporary PFA order on Dec. 15, Mr. Karr went to live with his mother in South Park. Detectives were told that floral wiring had gone missing from the mother’s garage, and they found the wire used to bind Mrs. Karr appeared to be the same, the complaint said. One end of the wire around Mrs. Karr’s hands was still in its packaging, and it was almost identical to the kind found in the mother’s garage.

Paula Meigs, Mrs. Karr's sister, said she did not know the extent of her sister’s troubled marriage until she told her family on Christmas. “This was bothering her,” she said. “She was afraid of him.”

The details, Mrs. Meigs said, were startling. Over the course of her 14-year marriage to Mr. Karr, her sister told them, he would become enraged and break items in the home. Three years ago, she obtained a PFA order against him after he pulled her down stairs, injuring her ribs and hip on October 23, 2011. Mrs. Karr told the responding officers that her husband was intoxicated and that he fled into the basement with lighter fluid, threatening to set the house on fire, the complaint said. Once the officers placed him under arrest, he told him he could “make himself have a seizure” by banging his head on the patrol car.

Advertise with us

The last incident occurred Dec. 12, according to Mrs. Karr’s PFA statement.

“James threw glass bottles out onto the street,” she wrote. “He was [threatening] to set the house on fire. After I [fled] the house to a neighbor’s. We witnessed his going outside [and] stabbing my tires, flattening all [four]. James then pulled [a] car window down [and] threw sewing machine [and] ceiling fan on the street.”

Some neighbors who spoke to reporters Tuesday confirmed her accounts. Others were somewhat caught off guard.

“We never heard them arguing,” said Frances Kinner, who lives across the street. “They must have done everything behind closed doors.”

Mrs. Karr also cited “numerous harassing [and] name-calling phone calls.”

Advertise with us

“I didn’t have a clue until she told us that day. She said she threw him out,” Mrs. Meigs said. “It was all new to us, but it didn’t surprise me. I asked her why she didn’t do it before. She said, ‘I’ve just had it. I’ve had enough.’ I think he was dependent on her for everything. He couldn’t function on his own.”

The most disturbing detail foreshadowed the tragedy.

“She said he gave her an ax and told her to keep it by the bedroom door in case the house caught on fire,” Mrs. Meigs said. “She would be able to get out of the house with the ax. And he did threaten to burn the house down, too.”

One witness told detectives that they gave Mr. Karr a ride from his mother's house to Duquesne on Monday to go to a mutual friend's house. Mr. Karr disappeared about 8:45 p.m. and did not run into the witness again until about midnight on Tuesday. Mr. Karr then asked the witness to take him back to South Park.

Another witness told detectives that they called Mr. Karr to report seeing smoke coming from the residence, worried because Mrs. Karr's car was outside. His response was “nonchalant” because he no longer lived there, the complaint read.

Advertise with us

Mr. Karr had previous run-ins with the law, including an October 1990 charge of arson and causing a catastrophe and criminal mischief. That case was withdrawn in 1992. He also was placed on five years’ probation for theft in 1993 and charged in a May 2004 DUI case in which he fled from police.

“He’s got problems,” Mrs. Meigs said. “I dealt with it because he was her husband. We knew, but we didn’t know it was as serious as it was. She didn’t tell us.”

Mrs. Karr was one of seven children growing up in the Wilson section of Clairton. The family moved to West Mifflin when her father got a job as a welder at U.S. Steel’s Irvin Works. Her mother, Norma Gecan, worked at the local Kmart and still lives in the same house with one of her younger daughters.

“It was hectic and we had our moments,” Mrs. Meigs said. “But as we got older, we all got along very well. We’ve had good times over the years.”

Settling down in Duquesne, Mrs. Karr worked two jobs, one as a receptionist with UPMC Ob/​Gyn on Curry Hollow Road in Pleasant Hills. The other was a regular evening duty, caring for a neighbor’s daughter who has a disability.

Advertise with us

The home was empty late Tuesday afternoon. A white truck was parked out front as men boarded up windows and doors. A thin white cross with a blue rosary wrapped around the top lay on the brick facade in front, near the loosened police caution tape on the sidewalk. Two bouquets of pink roses were also displayed.

James and Christine Kelley, who live next door, described Mrs. Karr as “a very nice lady and nice neighbor.”

“We’re going to miss her,” Mr. Kelley said.

Mrs. Karr’s marriage to Mr. Karr was her first, her sister said. Mr. Karr has at least two children from a previous marriage, family court records show.

Jefferson Memorial Funeral Home in Pleasant Hills is handling arrangements.

Dan Majors: dmajors@post-gazette.com. Madasyn Czebiniak: mczebiniak@post-gazette.com