The way James Karr told it to a detective, the death of his wife — found wrapped in wire and dead inside her charred home — was “an accident.” But parts of that story don’t align with physical evidence, according to testimony given in court Friday morning.

Officials located Mr. Karr, 47, shortly after they learned that the Duquesne home from which he had recently been evicted, and where his wife still lived, was destroyed by flames Dec. 30. For hours, he remained in Allegheny County police headquarters “denying any knowledge” about the death of 56-year-old Maureen Karr, who had received a protective order against him the day before, Detective Steven Hitchings said.

Late that evening, Mr. Karr began to talk in more detail. Part of his statement was recounted in a hearing Friday morning, at which District Judge James Motznik ordered Mr. Karr to stand trial on charges of homicide, arson and animal cruelty — for two dogs that died in the fire as well.

Mr. Karr told Detective Hitchings he had been addicted to crack cocaine in recent years and “just wanted to make things work out better.” He told police he drank and did crack in the hours before the fire, then went to his wife’s Friendship Street house and entered through the back door, angering her.

Advertise with us

His wife came at him with an ax, Mr. Karr said, and he pushed her, causing her to fall backward. Ms. Karr didn't move, Mr. Karr said, so he tried to resuscitate her and, when that failed, dragged her to the living room, wrapped wire around her arms, legs and neck, and poured vodka on her and then on the front door and lit it on fire.

Detective Hitchings said investigators didn’t find an ax or an empty vodka bottle but noted, “The house was a total loss.”

One of Ms. Karr’s relatives previously said Mr. Karr bought his wife an ax and “told her to keep it by the bedroom door in case the house caught on fire. She would be able to get out of the house with the ax.”

During the interview, police asked Mr. Karr to draw a sketch showing where furniture and outlets were located inside the house. That information, combined with burn patterns, led investigators to suspect the fire began in the living room, deputy fire marshal George Stouffer said.

Deputy Stouffer went to the home shortly after midnight and arrived to find flames “coming out of every window, every doorway of the house.” When the fire was out, he walked through the house. In the living room, he said, he noticed an area where the burn marks were lighter in color.

Advertise with us

He used a piece of wood to move some of the charred material out of the way and felt soft tissue. “That's when I realized that I had discovered a victim,” he said.

He noticed wire around the person’s neck, then hands, then feet. Near her head was the body of a dog.

As Detective Hitchings took Mr. Karr from headquarters to a police car, “He asked about the dogs. Did the dogs get out?”

Mr. Karr told the detective he had attempted to let the dogs out. Public defender Lisa Middleman unsuccessfully tried to argue that meant he should not be charged with animal cruelty.

Ms. Middleman said after the hearing that she looks forward to reviewing the recordings of Mr. Karr’s time with police and some of the forensic evidence about the fire, saying, “fire science is a little bit voodoo rather than a ... science.”

“I’ve won tougher ones,” she said.