Masks will stay on in the North Allegheny and Upper St. Clair school districts at least until a federal appellate court hearing late next month to address dueling appeals unless the rate of COVID transmission drops between now and then.
The 3rd U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said Friday that it will hold a hearing on both cases on March 24 by Zoom.
School boards in both districts recently voted to reverse mandatory masking policies, prompting federal lawsuits by groups of at-risk students and their parents who said attending schools where masks are optional could expose them to COVID and violate the Americans with Disabilities Act.
The suits resulted in opposite decisions by judicial colleagues on the federal bench in Pittsburgh.
In the North Allegheny case, Judge Marilyn Horan sided with the students and temporarily forced the district to reinstate masks for everyone. The school district appealed that decision to the 3rd Circuit.
In the Upper St. Clair case, Judge William Stickman IV sided with the school board and ruled that masks will stay optional, saying the school board is the authority on policy matters. The students appealed, and the 3rd Circuit overturned Judge Stickman temporarily pending a fuller review.
The circuit court said both cases will be consolidated and heard on March 24, although an immediate ruling on that date is unlikely, so masks will stay on until the judges decide.
Attorney Ken Behrend, who represents the students, said masks will remain in place in the districts until a ruling unless the rate of transmission drops below the "substantial" category.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.