Attorneys on both sides of a bitter court dispute over the fortune of the late billionaire publisher Richard Mellon Scaife met Wednesday before Westmoreland County President Judge Richard E. McCormick Jr. for a status conference on a challenge to the will.
Judge McCormick ordered attorneys for the estate to respond, in 20 days, to discovery requests from Jennie Scaife, the late publisher’s daughter. He said that following the production of documents, if the dispute continues, he will schedule oral arguments.
Judge McCormick is hearing Ms. Scaife’s challenge to her father’s will, which the late publisher signed, with three initials, in February 2013. The will did not mention the 52-year-old daughter, who lives in Florida, nor her brother, David Scaife, 49, of Shadyside.
Ms. Scaife contends that attorney H. Yale Gutnick exercised “undue influence” over her father, resulting in the transfer of assets to the Tribune-Review newspapers. Mr. Gutnick is the chairman of the board of the Tribune-Review newspapers, a trustee in several Scaife family foundations and executor of the estate.
Ms. Scaife’s attorneys have contended that Mr. Scaife left millions to the Tribune-Review, which they have characterized as a waste.
Mr. Gutnick’s legal team has countered that even a prior will, signed in 2008, left nothing to the son and daughter. If the 2013 will was to be invalidated, the 2008 will would likely supplant it.
Read More
Attorney William Pietragallo, representing Ms. Scaife, conceded that if the 2008 will and related codicils are upheld, then Ms. Scaife “would be eliminated.” But he wants to explore whether that will was proper.
Attorney Trent A. Echard, representing Mr. Gutnick and his co-executor, James M. Walton, has asked the judge to dismiss Ms. Scaife’s petition.
Mr. Pietragallo said that Ms. Scaife’s challenge would not impede bequests to the Brandywine Conservancy or the Westmoreland Museum of American Art, but could hold up the flow of assets to two foundations and the Tribune-Review.
Richard Mellon Scaife died July 4, 2014. His will also divided control of trust funds that held more than $700 million between the Sarah Scaife Foundation and the Allegheny Foundation.
A separate challenge filed by Mr. Scaife’s son and daughter in November in Allegheny County alleges that Mr. Gutnick and two other trustees improperly allowed Mr. Scaife to drain a trust fund of $450 million, largely to subsidize the Tribune-Review.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.