Attorneys representing Richard Mellon Scaife’s son filed objections Monday to subpoenas issued by a confidant and trustee to the late billionaire publisher.
Four subpoenas issued by attorney H. Yale Gutnick, who is chairman of the Tribune-Review newspaper’s board, are “solely for purposes of harassment and personal intrigue,” wrote attorneys for David Scaife, 49, of Shadyside. The objections place the dispute before Judge Kathleen A. Durkin.
Mr. Gutnick’s legal team sent the four subpoenas to the law firms K&L Gates and Reed Smith, to attorney Sanford B. Ferguson and to Bank of New York Mellon. The subpoenas seek “personal and confidential information of David,” outside of the scope of the ongoing legal fight between the son and three trustees, according to the objections.
Attorney E.J. Strassburger, representing Mr. Gutnick, wrote in an email to the Post-Gazette that the subpoenas were not for harassment, but rather for “seeking relevant evidence.”
The subpoena dispute comes just a month into a discovery process expected to continue into next year.
David Scaife and his sister, Jennie Scaife, 52, last year launched their legal challenge to the actions of Mr. Gutnick and fellow trustees James M. Walton and PNC Bank. The trustees controlled a fund created in 1935 by Sarah Mellon Scaife, which over 20 years distributed roughly $450 million, largely to support the Tribune-Review.
Read More
The trustees “knew well that Richard Mellon Scaife had considerable personal wealth available to him to finance his hobby without raiding the 1935 Trust,” wrote attorneys for the daughter and son in additional court filings Monday.
The son and daughter, who were to receive any money remaining in the fund upon their father’s death, have argued that the distributions violated the terms of the trust by allowing it to run dry, and are seeking a nine-figure recovery. The trustees have maintained that spending on newspapers and philanthropy was consistent with the trust terms.
Jennie Scaife has also challenged the validity of her father’s will, which mentioned neither the daughter nor son.
The will split control of most of the late publisher’s remaining trust funds between the Sarah Scaife Foundation and the Allegheny Foundation.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.