A decision by the Montour School District to eliminate its free pre-kindergarten program as a cost-cutting measure last week has upset parents who now must find an alternative.
The pre-K was made available for up to 60 district students Mondays through Fridays on a first-come, first-served basis at Burkett Elementary in Robinson as a pilot program for 2014-15.
Plans had been made to include classroom space for the half-day program at the district’s new combined elementary school being constructed at the high school campus on Clever Road in Robinson.
Parents said they learned of the possible closure three days before the meeting during which the board voted 6-0 to close the pre-K. Directors Joyce Snell, Scott Suess and Darrell Young were absent.
The program cost about $340,000 to maintain annually and included salary for two teachers and two paraprofessionals, according to the district. Officials expected to receive a maximum reimbursement of $41,000 from the state, but the district is ineligible for the money because it did not register the program with the state, said deputy superintendent Michael Ghilani.
“My heart is with your children that [pre-K] is something we should do for them,” said Mr. Ghilani, who started with the district Jan. 15. But as a “steward of the district,” he said, dollars spent now may come back to haunt the parents and their children in the future.
Several parents brought along their children to request the district wait until next year to make this decision.
Kennedy parent Sarah Brallier told directors they “brought kids tonight so you can see faces as opposed to dollar signs.” She and other parents said the decision should have been made much earlier in the year, prior to registration and students touring their new school.
A small group of 4-year-old girls approached board President Dean Caliguire saying, “Don’t close our school. We love school because it’s fun.”
Mr. Caliguire had earlier said, “It’s not with any joy that we do any of this.”
The district finds itself in a tight situation, with issues such as rising Public School Employees' Retirement System contributions and dropping property values because of commercial assessment appeals. Montour will use a large portion of its fund balance in its budget for 2015-16.
“The late hour of this decision gives concerned parents such as myself, my wife and those with children enrolled in this program little time, if any, to find suitable alternative arrangements,” parent James Hoy, of Robinson, told directors.
“This program has put stress, strain and in some cases unsustainable burden on area preschools, which fulfilled the same educational needs that your pre-K program offered for one year. As such, finding alternative placement at this time is difficult at best, and virtually impossible for most of us. This treatment is unfair and affects a great number of district parents,” he said.
For now, affected parents are deciding if they will keep their children at home next year, make scheduling changes to accommodate different schools’ hours or adjust household budgets to be able to afford private pre-K. Even with the closure of Robinson’s Forest Grove Learning Center at the end of 2014-15, there are still several local options available in the district, ranging from $170 to $300 per month.
Registration at Kennedy-based St. Malachy School is full, but the parochial school is offering to let parents join a waiting list for half-day pre-K programming five days per week.
Located near Forest Grove Elementary in Robinson, Little Footsteps Learning Center decided to offer a pre-K class as a direct result of Montour closing its program. As of Monday, about 12 openings were available, and several parents had been by the location to pick up registration forms, said Kristen Stern, pre-K and preschool teacher.
The center had not initially planned to include a pre-K offering next year because need was not apparent.
The pre-K there was traditionally filled by students who had already attended preschool there as 4-year-olds. They did not qualify to enroll in Montour’s full-day kindergarten because of their birth dates or because their parents wanted them to have an additional year of part-time school, director Chrissy Michelangelo said.
“We thought we could help out because they put the parents in a tough situation,” she said. Little Footsteps pre-K will meet 9 to 11:30 a.m. Monday through Thursday.
Judy Albenze, Crafton Children’s Corner founder and executive director, said the Thornburg location of her school has at least 20 openings for pre-K because a classroom earmarked for full-day kindergarten at the center could be used for pre-kindergarten. The kindergarten was not a planned offering for the upcoming year because of low enrollment.
Pre-K programming at the Thornburg center will be available in the mornings Monday, Wednesday and Friday.
Holy Trinity School in Robinson was on summer hours and unable to be reached for comment.
“[This decision] breaks my heart; it’s been a tough week,” recently appointed school director Kenneth Barth said. He apologized for the move, saying the board has to look at the needs of the whole as compared to the needs of a few.
Montour encompasses the suburbs of Ingram, Kennedy, Pennsbury Village, Robinson and Thornburg and serves more than 2,800 students.
Sonja Reis, freelance writer: suburbanliving@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.