A jury’s impasse Friday spared the life of a Pittsburgh man convicted of killing a Beaver County couple six years ago.
The 12-person panel told Senior Judge John P. Dohanich of Beaver County Common Pleas Court that it couldn’t decide whether Robert L. Burgess, 37, should be sentenced to death or life in prison without the possibility of parole.
If a jury cannot reach a unanimous decision in the penalty phase of a trial, the defendant automatically receives a life sentence without parole. Judge Dohanich will formally sentence Mr. Burgess at a hearing Nov. 26.
Thomas N. Farrell, one of the Mr. Burgess’ court-appointed attorneys, said the jury was “clearly hopelessly deadlocked” after 3½ hours of deliberation Friday.
“We were disappointed with the verdict, but we were happy we didn’t get the death penalty,” he said.
The jury found Mr. Burgess guilty Tuesday of two counts of first-degree murder and related crimes for his part in the shooting deaths of Richard and Demetria Harper, both 32, in their Beaver Falls home. Prosecutors said the killings stemmed from a drug-related dispute.
Read More
Investigators said Mr. Burgess of the North Side and his co-defendant, Devon Shealey, 28, locked the couple’s daughters in the basement furnace room, then hog-tied their parents and shot them in the head on June 30, 2008. The children, then 8 and 10, were not harmed. Both now live in New Mexico with their grandparents and testified during the trial and penalty phase.
According to court documents, Mr. Burgess, Shealey and Mrs. Harper devised a plan to sell marijuana that involved Mrs. Harper going to El Paso, Texas — where she used to live — to buy pot and ship it back so the three could sell it. The scheme crumbled, though, when Mrs. Harper was arrested for marijuana possession at a random checkpoint in Texas.
Mr. Burgess told his cousin Tyrone Beasley that he was “mad as hell” because he believed Mrs. Harper stole the money he’d given her to buy the marijuana, and when his cousin asked, Mr. Burgess “confirmed he did the killings of the Harpers,” investigators wrote in criminal complaints.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.