From within a locked basement room, 8-year-old Iyana and 10-year-old LaNiya Harper listened to their parents crying after two armed, masked men barged into their Beaver Falls home and forced the family downstairs.
In the six years since then, they told a jury through tears and broken voices Wednesday, they have long wondered how they might have changed the outcome.
“I lay awake and ask myself, ‘At the age of 8, what could I have done to stop it? What could I have said?’ ” Iyana said.
“I felt like if I would have said something or came out of the closet,” her sister added, “my parents would still be alive.”
Their testimony came during the first phase of an emotional sentencing hearing Wednesday, a day after jurors convicted Robert L. Burgess, 37, of two counts of first-degree murder and related crimes in the shooting deaths of Richard and Demetria Harper, both 32.
The hearing is expected to continue today with additional defense testimony and final arguments.
Read More
Beaver County prosecutors are seeking the death penalty.
The couple’s daughters separately told jurors how the murders have changed them, reading in part from their own handwritten notes.
“This isn’t something I can just wake up and forget,” said LaNiya, now 17. “It’s like every time I close my eyes and try to fall asleep, all I see is my mom and dad in that puddle of blood.”
“June 30,” she added, “my whole life was taken from me.”
That day, according to investigators, Burgess, of the North Side, and his co-defendant, Devon Shealey, 28, locked the girls in the furnace room, then bound their parents and shot them in the head, also in the basement. The children were not harmed.
According to court documents, Burgess, Shealey and Mrs. Harper devised a plan to sell marijuana that involved Mrs. Harper going to El Paso, Texas — where she used to live — to buy pot and ship it back so the three could sell it.
The scheme crumbled, though, when Mrs. Harper was arrested for marijuana possession at a random checkpoint in Texas.
Burgess told his cousin Tyrone Beasley that he was “mad as hell” because he believed Mrs. Harper stole the money he’d given her to buy the marijuana, according to court documents.
When his cousin asked, Burgess “confirmed he did the killings of the Harpers,” investigators wrote in criminal complaints.
Mr. Harper’s family has said he was not involved in the plan.
For his part, Shealey was convicted of second-degree murder in June and sentenced to two life terms.
Burgess’ defense team Wednesday called witnesses to testify about his character and recount events in his childhood.
“There’s much more dimension to him than what occurred on that day,” said his attorney Mitchell Shahen.
A longtime neighbor told jurors that Burgess, whom she described as always nice and respectful in his youth, had suffered head injuries in an accident involving a motorcycle when he was 7 or 8 years old.
Testimony from onetime fellow inmate Isaiah Paillet suggested that Burgess might have hesitated before carrying out the act.
“Shealey said he gave him the look like, what are you waiting on?” just before the killings, Paillet said.
Of Burgess, Paillet added: “He’s just not known in the neighborhood for being a killer — amongst a bunch of killers.”
Burgess’ prior convictions include cocaine possession with the intent to deliver and assault.
Both Harper girls now live with their grandparents in New Mexico.
They have two other siblings there: Ashanta Williams, 21, a third-year college student, and Sir Donta Harper, 18, who plans to enlist in the Army.
Both sisters said they especially miss their father’s laughter and how he always called out “Family!” when he got home.
“My point is, I can’t see them anymore,” Iyana said. “And pictures are not the same.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.