A North Side man convicted of first-degree murder Tuesday in the killing of a Beaver Falls couple six years ago is set to be sentenced this morning.

Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty for Robert L. Burgess, 37, in the deaths of Richard and Demetria Harper, both 32, who were shot execution-style in their home after a drug-related dispute.

The Beaver County jury returned the guilty verdict shortly before 6 p.m., after more than six hours of deliberation that capped off two weeks of testimony.

Prosecutors said Burgess and another man, Devon Shealey, went to the Harpers’ Beaver Falls home on June 30, 2008, and after locking the couple’s daughters, then 8 and 10, in a basement furnace room, hog-tied the couple and shot them in the head.

Advertise with us

Mr. Harper’s sister discovered the bodies. The children were not harmed.

According to court documents, Burgess, Shealey, 28, and Mrs. Harper devised a plan to sell marijuana that involved Mrs. Harper going to El Paso, Texas, where she used to live, to buy pot and ship it back to Beaver Falls so the three could sell it.

The scheme fell apart, though, when Mrs. Harper said she was arrested for marijuana possession at a random checkpoint in Texas. Then, a friend of Mrs. Harper’s who acted as a go-between told Burgess that she saw a package had been delivered to Mrs. Harper’s home. Burgess told his cousin Tyrone Beasley that he was “mad as hell” because he believed Mrs. Harper stole the money he’d given her to buy the marijuana, according to court documents.

When his cousin asked, Burgess “confirmed he did the killings of the Harpers,” investigators wrote in criminal complaints.

Mr. Harper’s family contends, and testimony suggests, that Mr. Harper was not involved in the plan and had no knowledge of it.

Advertise with us

Burgess’ attorney, Thomas N. Farrell, declined to comment after the verdict was delivered, citing the ongoing proceeding.

Burgess’ co-defendant, Shealey, was convicted of second-degree murder in June and sentenced to two life terms. A public defender who represented him has said he plans to appeal the conviction.

Their arrests in 2012 followed a four-year investigation involving local, state and federal authorities. Prosecutors called nearly 50 witnesses for the Burgess trial, including some who traveled across the country to testify.

The Harpers’ children, who now live in New Mexico, testified earlier in the trial and were in court this week.