The sentencing phase continued today in the death penalty trial of a North Side man convicted of killing a Beaver Falls couple in 2008.

Robert Burgess' defense team called several witnesses, including Burgess' mother and father, who provided conflicting accounts about events in his childhood.

Burgess' mother testified that her son's father, Edward Burgess, mentally, physically and sexually abused her across several years. Court records show he was convicted of raping her in 1984, but the Post-Gazette does not name victims of sexual assault.

She also described an incident of inappropriate sexual contact involving the younger Mr. Burgess and his father, an allegation the elder man denied.

Advertise with us

In an unrelated case, Edward Burgess, 59, was convicted in 1991 of sexually assaulting four girls ranging from 10 to 12 years old, according to an online sex offender registry.

"Think about what he had to come home to," defense attorney Mitchell Shahen said. "Robert's life was one nightmare after another."

A jury on Tuesday convicted Burgess, 37, of two counts of first-degree murder and related crimes in the shooting deaths of Richard and Demetria Harper, both 32, that followed what investigators described as a drug-related dispute.

His co-defendant Devon Shealey, 28, was found guilty of second-degree murder in June and ordered to serve two life terms for his part.