A jury is to begin deliberations today in the trial of a North Side man accused of killing a Beaver County couple after their plans to sell marijuana collapsed six years ago.
Robert L. Burgess, 37, is charged with homicide and related crimes for his alleged role in the shooting deaths of Richard and Demetria Harper, both 32. Prosecutors are seeking the death penalty in the case, a culmination of an investigation that involved local, state and federal authorities.
Police said Burgess and his co-defendant, Devon Shealey, went to the Harpers’ Beaver Falls home on June 30, 2008, and after locking the couple’s daughters, who were 8 and 10, in a basement furnace room, hog-tied the couple and shot them in the head.
Mr. Harper’s sister discovered the bodies. The children were unharmed.
Thomas N. Farrell, a court-appointed attorney representing Burgess, argued in closing remarks Monday that Burgess wasn’t at the Harper home that day and said prosecutors failed to link him to the crime scene.
“My client did not commit a robbery, a murder, a burglary, any of that,” Mr. Farrell said.
Assistant District Attorney Jennifer Popovich contended that Shealey, 28, and Burgess targeted the couple because of a drug-related dispute.
According to court documents, Burgess, Shealey and Mrs. Harper devised a plan to sell marijuana that involved Mrs. Harper traveling to El Paso, Texas, where she used to live, to buy 15 and 20 pounds of the drug. She would then mail the marijuana to Beaver Falls, and the trio would sell it.
The plan crumbled on June 26, 2008 when Mrs. Harper was arrested for marijuana possession at a random checkpoint in Texas.
A friend of Mrs. Harper told Burgess that he’d been ripped off, and Burgess told his cousin Tyrone Beasley that he was “mad as hell” because he believed Mrs. Harper stole the money he’d given her to buy the marijuana.
When Mr. Beasley asked, Burgess “confirmed he did the killings of the Harpers,” according to criminal complaints.
“Use your common sense,” Ms. Popovich told jurors. “It’s time for Robert Burgess to get his.”
In his argument, Mr. Farrell characterized the witnesses as unreliable and that they had been “manipulated by the police.”
He also accused a detective investigating the case of “bullying all of these witnesses.”
Shealey was found guilty in June of second-degree murder and sentenced to two consecutive life terms.
A public defender who represented him has said he planned to appeal the conviction.
The Harpers’ daughters, who now live in New Mexico, testified earlier in the trial that they had to walk past their parents’ bodies to get out of the basement where they’d been locked up.
As prosecutors showed jurors a photo of the couple, bound and bloodied, during closing remarks Monday, the girls gasped and covered their faces.
The couple also had a son, now 18.
Both defendants were incarcerated at the time of their arrests in June 2012: Burgess was serving a 51-month sentence for cocaine possession with the intent to deliver; Shealey was serving a four-year sentence for assault with a deadly weapon in relation to racketeering.
Senior Common Pleas Judge John P. Dohanich of Beaver County is presiding.
Molly Born: mborn@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1944.The Associated Press contributed.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.