A former Donora councilman has been charged with food stamp fraud at the deli he owns.
Investigators allege that Jimmie B. Coulter gave money to customers in exchange for food stamps — something that is illegal — and pocketed some of the cash on multiple occasions.
Mr. Coulter, 63, was arraigned Friday on several felony counts including buying/exchanging federal food stamps, fraudulent traffic in food orders and theft by deception. He was released on $10,000 bond and faces a May 9 preliminary hearing before Bentleyville District Judge Curtis Thompson.
“Believe me, it’s something I”m gonna win, hands down,” Mr. Coulter said. “Look forward to it.”
Mr. Coulter's attorney, Steven Toprani, said he had not yet been able to review the charging documents but nonetheless defended his client.
“Mr. Coulter is disputing these charges, and he’s maintaining his innocence," Mr. Toprani said.
Mr. Coulter, 63, was arraigned Friday on several felony counts including buying/exchanging federal food stamps, fraudulent traffic in food orders and theft by deception. He was released on $10,000 bond and faces a May 9 preliminary hearing before Bentleyville District Judge Curtis Thompson.
“Believe me, it’s something I”m gonna win, hands down,” Mr. Coulter said. “Look forward to it.”
Mr. Coulter's attorney, Steven Toprani, said he had not yet been able to review the charging documents but nonetheless defended his client.
“Mr. Coulter is disputing these charges, and he’s maintaining his innocence," Mr. Toprani said.
Mr. Coulter, who was a councilman from 2014 through last year, runs Ondray’s Store on Allen Avenue.
The case grew out of a notification in August by the U.S. Department of Agriculture to the Pennsylvania State Police about “questionable” transactions at Ondray’s.
An investigation using confidential informants, an undercover trooper and a grand jury revealed that Mr. Coulter would give 50 cents on the dollar to food stamp recipients who are enrolled in the Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP), according to an affidavit and grand jury presentment.
According to the presentment, a copy of the SNAP training guide for retails was found at Mr. Coulter’s store. It spelled out that it is illegal to exchange cash for welfare benefits. The presentment also said an application filled out by Mr. Coulter to participate as a retailer in the food stamp program “contained a certification page that specifically addressed the prohibition on trading cash for food stamp benefits...”
Mr. Coulter’s signature appeared on the certification page under a statement warning of criminal and civil penalties, the presentment said.
While investigators were executing a search warrant at the store, Mr. Coulter spoke with police.
He exhibited an “in-depth understanding” of the SNAP program, said he knew it was illegal to trade food stamps for cash and “admitted to investigators that he may have exchanged a small amount of cash for food stamp benefits but it only occurred on one or two occasions,” the presentment said.
“He denied engaging in this illegal activity on a regular basis and denied providing large sums of cash.”
A state police investigator told the grand jury that he interviewed seven or eight people who said they sold their food stamps to Mr. Coulter in exchange for cash, the presentment said. A confidential informant made one purchase from Mr. Coulter, ringing up a $101.50 transaction for $1.50 worth of food and then splitting the $100 in cash with the informant, according to the presentment.
The presentment said that an undercover trooper then made a half-dozen similar transactions.
Jonathan D. Silver: jsilver@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1962 or on Twitter @jsilverpg.
This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.