Battle lines are set for a court hearing this week to determine if a former UPMC claims director should go to federal prison or get probation for embezzling nearly $850,000 by placing his wife and another person on the health system's payroll as ghost employees.
Ronald Locy, who pleaded guilty in January 2017 to one count of embezzlement, will be sentenced Wednesday in U.S. District Court. He turns 50 that day.
The U.S. attorney’s office says Mr. Locy, formerly of Washington County and now living in Washington state, deserves up to three years behind bars because of the scale of the theft and the calculated nature of the crime over seven years.
Mr. Locy and his lawyer want a “non-custodial” sentence of the type often requested by white-collar defendants with no prior criminal history, in part because of the death of his young daughter in 2012 after years of illness.
Federal fraud sentences like this one often boil down to a similar tug-of-war between prosecutors and defense attorneys.
Lawyers typically say defendants, who are usually not violent nor at much risk to re-offend, have already paid for their crime with the loss of a job, reputation or family and so should not be punished further, especially if they are paying the money back.
Prosecutors usually say fraudsters should go to prison because giving them probation sends the message to society that white-collar crime pays or that rich people enjoy a different justice system than the poor.
The most prominent example of the debate in this district, cited in other prosecutions here for years, is that of wealthy Washington County contractor William G. Tomko, who pleaded guilty to tax evasion in connection with work done on his $5 million mansion.
In 2005, the late U.S. District Judge Gary Lancaster caused a ruckus when he gave Tomko probation and let him serve the first year of it inside the very house that his fraud helped build.
The sentence is still often derided by prosecutors and some judges as the “gilded cage” punishment.
The Justice Department protested, but an appellate court upheld the decision with some dissent.
Mr. Locy, like Tomko and many other white-collar criminals, says he has already suffered from his actions and that locking him up will serve no purpose.
“The publicity from his guilty plea has caused Mr. Locy great humiliation and embarrassment among his family, friends, business colleagues and other peers,” his lawyer, Martin Dietz, wrote. “This informal form of punishment has been real and severe. Mr. Locy is virtually unemployable in health care, an industry in which he worked for nearly his entire adult life.”
Mr. Dietz said Friday he couldn’t comment before the sentencing, but in court papers he also cited the illness and death of Mr. Locy’s daughter, Cameron, as a reason for leniency. The girl, born prematurely, died in 2012 at age 8 after years of treatment and medical emergencies. The Locy couple have two other adult children.
Mr. Dietz said his client “lost his way” while dealing with the stress of the child’s health problems and then keeping his family together after the girl died.
“His family was, to say the least, in complete turmoil and Mr. Locy made a tragically terrible decision,” Mr. Dietz said.
He has presented numerous letters from friends and family on his client's behalf.
In addition, Mr. Locy’s sister, Toni Locy, a former Pittsburgh Press reporter and a professor at Washington and Lee University in Virginia, plans to testify at the sentencing,
Mr. Locy took a health care job in Texas after UPMC fired him in 2014 but lost that job after his new company received a grand jury subpoena for his personnel file in relation to the Pittsburgh case. He has since been running a HoneyBaked Ham franchise his sister owns in Olympia, Wash., turning it into a profitable enterprise.
Mr. Dietz said Mr. Locy is contrite and will pay back the money he stole. He has entered into a settlement agreement to pay restitution to the insurance company that covered UPMC's loss claim for the embezzled money. He has paid $90,000 so far.
The U.S. attorney’s office said that effort is laudable, as is the support network Mr. Locy enjoys, but prosecutors want U.S. District Judge David Cercone to impose a sentence in the guideline range of 30 to 37 months.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Robert Cessar said Mr. Locy’s crime was not a one-time offense but a long-running scheme.
“Over approximately a seven-year period, [Locy] was faced with a decision over and over again — should I steal from my employer?” Mr. Cessar wrote in pre-sentence filings. “Time and time again, the defendant, motivated by greed, answered that question ‘yes’ and engaged in the repeated acts of theft. Those repeated decisions reveal the unpleasant side of the defendant’s character.”
Mr. Locy was the senior director at UPMC Health Plan Claims since 2010.
From 2005 to 2013, Mr. Cessar said, he placed his wife, Tracy, on the payroll even though she was not an employee and did no work. As a result, UPMC's plan paid her wages and bonuses totaling $785,145.
Mr. Locy also falsified documents, such as performance reviews, to be entered into the health plan’s database to support her “work” and altered emails to reflect the bonus payments.
Mrs. Locy was supposedly working from home, Mr. Cessar said, but in truth did nothing.
She was not charged in the case and her role in the scheme, if any, remains unclear.
In addition to her, Mr. Locy also caused a second person to be placed on the UPMC payroll for another $61,000. That individual has not been identified publicly.
In all, Mr. Locy stole $846,819.
In addition to punishment for the crime, Mr. Cessar argued that a jail sentence is necessary as a deterrent to other embezzlers in the local health care industry because federal agents can’t catch them all.
“The Pittsburgh area includes two large medical insurance companies, UPMC and Highmark. The defendant’s sentence will become known throughout these and other insurance providers,” he said. “The government simply does not have the resources or expertise to detect, much less investigate and prosecute, every instance of health care fraud or embezzlement.”
Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.