A former UPMC claims director is headed to federal prison for two years for stealing close to a million dollars by placing his wife and his family’s nanny on the hospital giant's payroll even though neither worked there.

U.S. District Judge David Cercone on Wednesday rejected Ronald Locy's request for probation, which was based largely on his contention that he was under duress because his young daughter needed around-the-clock medical care for a neurological condition before her death in 2012.

The judge said probation was not an option because it wouldn't deter other would-be white-collar thieves, which is always a consideration in federal fraud cases.

He said a fair percentage of people, if given a choice, would take a federal probation sentence in exchange for $1 million.

Advertise with us

"What message would it send if I were to impose probation?" he asked.

The judge also noted that the crime was relatively sophisticated and lasted for eight years, hardly the kind of one-time aberration triggered by extreme stress.

He did, however, cut Locy a break.

He could have given him the guideline range of 30 to 37 months, which is what the U.S. attorney's office requested.

Locy, 50, formerly of Washington County and now of Olympia, Wash., was the senior director at UPMC Health Plan Claims since 2010 until he was fired in 2014. He pleaded guilty in Jan. 2017 to one count of embezzlement.

Advertise with us

From 2005 to 2013, he placed his wife, Tracy, on the payroll as a ghost employee. Prosecutors did not charge her, nor was she a witness.

The plan ended up paying her wages and bonuses totaling $785,145. After the death of their daughter, Cameron, at age 8, he also placed his nanny, Autumn Weir, on the UPMC payroll, costing UPMC another $62,000.

Ms. Weir had helped care for the girl. The stolen money went to her but she also was not charged. Prosecutors are working on a plan to have her pay that money back.

In arguing for leniency, Locy's lawyer, Martin Dietz, had to overcome the problem of why the scheme lasted for so long and its sophistication.

The judge noted that Locy took specific steps to falsify records, alter emails and conceal what he was doing across the span of eight years.

Advertise with us

Assistant U.S. Attorney Robert Cessar said Locy entered false documents into the health plan's database to support his wife's "work" and changed emails to reflect the bonus payments.

Mrs. Locy was supposedly working from home, but in truth she did nothing.

In all, Locy stole $846,819. The judge ordered him to pay that amount in restitution.

In court, Locy issued only a brief statement to the judge, saying "I'm here to apologize to you, to Mr. Cessar and to my family. I have no excuses."

His sister, Toni Locy, a former Pittsburgh Press and USA Today reporter who is now a professor, read a long, dramatic account she wrote of the toll Cameron's illness and death had taken on her, her brother and the rest of the family. At one point, she said she was so caught up in Cameron's plight that her USA Today superiors denied her a raise because they said she was too distracted.

Advertise with us

The judge asked her if she considered embezzling from the paper. She said no.

He later said much of her recitation was "not relevant" and seemed to be a play for his sympathy.

Ms. Locy also recounted how her brother had made a new life for himself running her HoneyBaked Ham franchise in Olympia. She was hoping that the judge would let him continue working there while on probation.

"The store gave him a reason to go on," she said. "He's turning his life around."

The judge said he would allow a variance below the guideline range but said prison was necessary and that Locy knew prison was likely when he pleaded guilty.

Advertise with us

"It is an appropriate sentence," he said.

He allowed Locy to self-report to the U.S. marshals service in Washington State by May 4 to begin his sentence.

Torsten Ove: tove@post-gazette.com.