A massive mortgage fraud scheme from a decade ago resurfaced Friday when a federal judge re-sentenced a former top executive to seven years behind bars over the objections of a prosecutor who said the man's continued attempts to deflect blame are enough to make him "vomit."
U.S. District Judge Joy Flowers Conti imposed that term against David McCloskey, who formerly ran First Atlantic Financial in Washington County.
The new sentence, necessary because of an ineffective counsel claim, was substantially less than the 10 years the U.S. attorney's office wanted.
McCloskey will also get credit for time served, which is about 45 months, so will be out in a little more than three years.
McCloskey, appearing in prison orange and shackles, said he's been working out, studying and going to church in prison and promised he was a new man.
"I have something to give back," he said. "I am a compassionate person."
He also apologized to everyone he ripped off.
"I do care, your honor, and I'm sorry," he said.
Assistant U.S. Attorney Brendan Conway, who has prosecuted most of the mortgage fraud cases here, said McCloskey's sole interest then and now is money.
"The only motive here was unadulterated greed," he said.
He said McCloskey remains a con artist.
"A changed man?" he asked. "I don't think so."
He said that McCloskey has continued to deny being the leader of the conspiracy and, nearly 10 years after his indictment, is still trying to blame others. As an example, he said McCloskey has repeatedly tried to mitigate his role in the fraud by saying First Atlantic was in his mother's name, even though he was in charge.
"If I hear that one more time I think I'm going to vomit," Mr. Conway told the judge. "It's disgusting."
The McCloskey investigation has a tangled legal history. The case had been announced in 2010 as part of "Operation Stolen Dreams," a nationwide Justice Department take-down of mortgage fraudsters who had preyed on lenders and buyers during the housing bubble of the mid-2000s.
The U.S. attorney's mortgage fraud task force said McCloskey, 53, of Finleyville, brokered $33 million in fraudulent loans. The loan applications contained false representations related to borrowers' income and assets, which were supported by fake papers that McCloskey and his cronies drew up. One co-conspirator, Kenneth Cowden, prepared fake appraisals that overstated the values of properties serving as collateral for the loans. He pleaded guilty in 2007 and was sentenced to 45 months.
McCloskey was indicted in 2009 and pleaded guilty to wire fraud conspiracy the following year. But in 2012, before he was sentenced, he tried to withdraw his plea and said in an affidavit that he was innocent. He got into a tiff over that with his then-lawyer, Michael DeRiso.
Judge Conti granted his request to remove DeRiso from the case on ineffective counsel grounds and gave him a new lawyer.
McCloskey ended up withdrawing his motion to back out of the plea and the judge sentenced him in 2014 to 10 years. He appealed and lost.
But he then filed a motion to vacate his sentence in 2016, saying Mr. DeRiso hadn't informed him properly of the ramifications of withdrawing his plea and filing an affidavit that contradicted what he'd said in court when he pleaded.
The judge granted that motion and said she would re-sentence McCloskey.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.