Jeffrey Gillen, chief of police in California, Pa., said his officers diligently investigated reports of burglary and phone-tampering filed over the past three years by Evelyn Stepko, even speaking to one of the men later arrested in her death.

Twice, Chief Gillen said, the small department sought help from a state police forensics team.

But despite officers' combined efforts to find fingerprints or other evidence at her Coal Center home that could point to a culprit, nothing was found -- but not due to any lack of effort on the part of investigators, the chief said.

"Were there things that could have been done or should have been done? I don't think so," Chief Gillen said Monday.

Advertise with us

The burglaries were reported to have occurred Aug. 4, 2009, June 15, 2010, Feb. 2 of this year, and March 5, according to a state police affidavit. On May 22, Mrs. Stepko reported that her phone lines had been cut. Early on, California police interviewed her neighbor, David A. McClelland, 56, who is facing homicide and other charges in connection with the stabbing death last week of the 92-year-old Mrs. Stepko and the apparent theft of more than $80,000 from her home.

After the first burglary, she identified Mr. McClelland, who had cut her grass until recently, as a suspect.

A longtime widow with no children, Mrs. Stepko never mentioned her fears to relatives, who gathered in the borough's Rotary Park Monday night for a candlelight vigil in her memory. They said they were troubled to learn that police had spoken to Mr. McClelland but were unable to arrest him until she was killed.

"I'm angry," said Dee Stein, one of Mrs. Stepko's 12 nieces and nephews. "Why didn't they do something? Did they think she was senile? She was sharp as a tack."

Chief Gillen said the widow's reports of having thousands of dollars at a time stolen from her home seemed to contradict her living conditions.

Advertise with us

Mrs. Stepko's home lacked a toilet and shower even though it had electricity and running water, and she used an outhouse.

"That's how her mother and father lived," said Dolores Sprowls, another niece. "That was the era."

The women described their aunt as "eccentric" yet reserved, giving even those closest to her mere glimpses into her life. Her house was "disarranged," Ms. Sprowls said, and she stashed untold amounts of cash in drawers, shoeboxes and a safe, among other places. Despite the clutter, she kept meticulous track of what she had.

"She counted everything," Ms. Sprowls said, adding that an officer came to the house several times but could not find signs of trouble. "I don't think [the police] really understood her. I just wish she had said something to us."

Asked if police believed Mrs. Stepko's allegations, Chief Gillen said, "The house was always secure. There never appeared to be any forced entry into the house, including this time."

Advertise with us

Chief Gillen said Mrs. Stepko was somewhat secretive when police responded to her house.

One person police did not interview was another neighbor, Mr. McClelland's son, David J. McClelland, 36, a part-time police officer for Washington Township, Fayette County.

Chief Gillen said he did not know why officers did not speak to the man who also has been charged in the killing.

The close-knit community was still reeling from the shock of Mrs. Stepko's stabbing Monday, when about 100 residents gathered in the park to "heal," said JoAnne Harris, one of the organizers who came to know Mrs. Stepko while delivering her mail.

"It was such a tragedy in this community," she said. "Stuff like that doesn't happen around here."

Advertise with us

Mrs. Stepko's nieces and nephews checked in on her. The Friday before her death was spent running errands with Ms. Stein. Mrs. Stepko seemed fearless, even when Ms. Stein returned her to her home long after dark.

"She liked to do everything the old-fashioned way," she said. "That's why she was so tough. ... Nobody really knew the real Evelyn. She was a total mystery."

Also a mystery to relatives was how the McClellands knew she had so much cash and where she kept it. Relatives said the men had cut her grass, but she had recently hired someone else.

According to the affidavit supporting the arrests, police have put together a largely circumstantial case. In addition to tracking financial records, casino expenditures and other information, police said a fingerprint from a bloody glove at the scene was matched to the elder Mr. McClelland.

Court records show no criminal cases against either McClelland.

Advertise with us

The younger Mr. McClelland had financial problems, according to the police affidavit.

Mr. McClelland worked for Monongahela for about two years until March.

"For the first year, he looked like he could have had a career in law enforcement. Worked any shift any time. Very good attitude. Clean cut. Was doing a good job. And approximately a year ago, I started noticing his work started slipping. I would constantly have to remind him about putting his reports in, you have a hearing, make sure you show up for the hearing," Monongahela police Chief Brian Tempest said.

When a full-time slot opened up, the chief said he told Mr. McClelland he would not be a candidate. And eventually he suggested that Mr. McClelland move on, which he did.

Eventually, Mr. McClelland landed at the Washington Township department.

Advertise with us

Chief Tempest recalled that his former employee was guarded about his personal life, volunteering little information even when the two shared a 16-hour workday. He expressed shock and surprise at the arrest.

"It's a little bit embarrassing that it's a law enforcement officer. Really, you stop and try to think, were there any telltale signs he would commit a felony or be accused of committing a felony? Didn't see 'em. He went from a very good employee to an employee who just was not doing his required work. So what caused that, I don't know."