Charged with defiant trespass for refusing to leave a restaurant that said he made inappropriate remarks to female employees, Jan Ondra insisted he had behaved like a gentleman.
"Do you understand they have had numerous complaints on you?" District Justice Jay Weller asked Ondra, referring to managers of Texas Roadhouse in South Strabane.
"Your Honor," said Ondra, who represented himself during the March 2001 proceeding, "people are going to complain about me wherever I go."
Police and court records showed Ondra, 51, who told Weller people didn't understand him, also wore out his welcome at Eat'n Park and Applebee's restaurants in South Strabane.
At least three times, Ondra has been charged or cited for defiant trespass. Each time, he prevailed in court, and the latest victory, a May 24 state Superior Court ruling overturning his conviction in the Texas Roadhouse case, may force police departments to rethink the way they handle calls to remove unwanted patrons from public places.
"It has us treading lightly here," South Strabane police Chief Don Zofchak said. He said he hoped to appeal the ruling.
Having decided to bar Ondra because of his conduct on previous visits, Texas Roadhouse called police to remove him when he walked through the door Jan. 19 and Feb. 3, 2001.
But the court, rejecting the notion of open-ended banishment, said criminal law allowed Ondra to be removed only for misbehaving at the time. The restaurant and police acknowledged Ondra did nothing wrong during the several minutes he spent in the restaurant those two nights.
While the Ondra case dealt with a restaurant, the ruling potentially affects malls and other public venues that sometime want to bar visitors permanently for offenses such as theft, vandalism and rowdiness. Zofchak said the ruling muddied what he thought was a business owner's right to control access to his or her property.
"I've seen people thrown out of bars because they were Cleveland Browns fans," Zofchak said.
In court, Cliff Nickisher, Texas Roadhouse managing partner, described Ondra as a disruptive influence.
"On different occasions, he would make sexual innuendos to employees, many of which were very young -- 16-, 17-year-old hostesses," Nickisher testified at Weller's office.
Nickisher said Ondra made remarks to employees while they were line dancing and once followed an employee to her car. In court, Ondra denied acting inappropriately; Nickisher said he had no other reason to turn a customer away.
Unresolved is the $1 million lawsuit Ondra filed last year against Texas Roadhouse, South Strabane police, Weller and Washington County prosecutors, alleging an "evil conspiracy" to frame him for trespassing and portray him as a "pervert."
Zofchak said Ondra, an owner of rental properties who lives in South Strabane, once asked him from the back of the police car why he had been removed from a restaurant. He said he told Ondra, who's about 6 feet 2 inches tall and weighs 250 pounds, that others considered his behavior odd and troubling.
"He stares at people," Zofchak said. "He'll mumble things. Women become very intimidated by him."
Neither Ondra nor the lawyer who sometimes has represented him, Jack Connor, of Uniontown, could be reached for comment for this story. Court records portrayed Ondra as one familiar with the law and how to apply it.
In August 1998, South Strabane police cited Ondra for a summary count of trespassing, saying he returned to Eat'n Park after the restaurant told him to stay away.
Weller convicted him, but Ondra, representing himself, won an appeal before Common Pleas Judge Paul Pozonsky. Police and court records didn't say why the restaurant excluded Ondra, and Eat'n Park said it couldn't provide details about an incident six years ago.
When he appeared before Weller in the Texas Roadhouse case, Ondra showed familiarity with courtroom procedure and objected when Nickisher began describing complaints he received from others.
"Hearsay," Ondra said. Weller sustained the objection.
Testimony showed Ondra became an almost daily customer at Texas Roadhouse after the restaurant opened in October 1999. Twice, Nickisher said, he warned Ondra about his conduct.
Nickisher decided Jan. 19, 2001, to ban Ondra and asked him to leave as soon as he walked through the door. When Ondra refused, a restaurant employee called police.
Officers arrested Ondra, cited him for a summary offense of trespassing and released him in the restaurant parking lot. "I'll get millions for this one," a police report quoted Ondra as saying.
When Ondra returned Feb. 3, 2001, the restaurant again called police to remove him. Officers arrested Ondra, charged him with a misdemeanor count of trespassing and released him.
Ondra argued the restaurant and police had no grounds to remove him. Under state law, he said, he couldn't be prosecuted for trespassing if he were behaving lawfully in a place open to the public.
Weller, questioning Ondra's interpretation of the law, found him guilty of the summary count and held him for court on the misdemeanor charge.
Ondra appealed the summary conviction. At a hearing before Pozonsky, Connor won a reversal.
A jury convicted Ondra on the misdemeanor count. Ondra appealed, leading to the May 24 Superior Court ruling that incorporated the argument he had made at Weller's office.
Citing criminal law and a decision in a previous case, the three-judge panel said the restaurant and police shouldn't have removed Ondra unless he had been misbehaving at the time.
As an alternative, the court said, the restaurant could deal with his "boorish behavior" by going to civil court to seek an order barring Ondra from the establishment. Nickisher said Texas Roadhouse hadn't done that.
Though it was based partly on case law, the Superior Court ruling took police departments by surprise. McDonald police Chief Mark Dorsey called it "absurd."
He and other police chiefs said they customarily honored a business owner's wishes to remove a patron who had worn out his welcome, regardless of whether he were misbehaving at the time. "I'd not only remove him, but I'd issue him a citation for trespass," Dorsey said.
State police spokesman Jack Lewis and North Franklin police Chief Mark Kavakich said their departments would review the ruling.
Nickisher said last week that he stood by his decision to have Ondra removed. Pat Conway, chief executive officer of Pennsylvania Restaurant Association, said he would have handled the situation the same way.
Conway and Cliff Miller, an Eat'n Park vice president, said restaurants were loath to bar customers. Miller said a customer's conduct would have to be egregious.
"And it happens very, very infrequently. I mean, extremely infrequently," Miller said.
Yet Ondra's suit contends that Texas Roadhouse was so eager to exclude him it tried to frame him for trespassing.
"This entire evil conspiracy is not for criminal trespass. That charge is only the means to the end. The only immediate course of action to bar Ondra was to illegally use the police," Ondra said in his suit.
Ondra wrote the suit longhand. It follows the format and invokes the jargon of a professionally written suit, except that beneath his signature on some pages he included the notation "by the authority of Jesus Christ."
South Strabane police last received a call concerning Ondra in February. A police report said Ondra, barred from Applebee's, twice called company executive Sam Rothschild to press his case.
"In one conversation, Ondra asked Rothschild if he had seen the movie 'A Few Good Men.' He then told him to watch the movie thinking of him. ... Applebee's is not sure what to make of this and felt they should document it," the police report said.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.