A video of a fight in a Chartiers Valley High School bathroom posted Saturday on Facebook erupted into an intricate online web of misinformation, doxing and vitriol Wednesday, turning the subject of an ongoing investigation into a soundboard for national scrutiny in a matter of tweets.

As the week unfolded, thousands of shares and comments on social media fueled a narrative of the fight that glossed over crucial facts. In reality, the fight -- caught on video showing a girl trying to avoid being punched while she is wearing what appears to be a Muslim hijab -- is under investigation and no charges have been filed. Police haden't yet determined whether the incident was racially or religiously motivated or amounted to a hate crime.

On Twitter, though, a flawed narrative picked up traction declaring that the incident had already been deemed a hate crime -- influencing users to jump to conclusions and post personal information about the alleged perpetrator while also triggering a wave of threats against the teenager based solely on the video.

It all is a telling example of the power of social media and how it takes only a few prominent people sharing a post to draw eyeballs -- and commentary -- from across the globe. The Pittsburgh Post-Gazette traced the virality of the video back to a series of tweets, some that contained misinformation and others that promoted doxing, a practice that can steer hostile online commentary toward a target.

Advertise with us

The minute-long video of the fight, in which one young woman knocks another to the floor of a bathroom stall and hits her repeatedly, was first shared by a student at the high school. She asked her friends to spread it while encouraging the school district to take action against what she called "bullying." The post, which was made public to enable sharing, was shared more than 1,200 times as of Wednesday afternoon, garnering nearly 100,000 views.

Some of the hostility started there. Commenters to the post talked of beating up the alleged perpetrator "till she starts speaking a different language," called her explicit names and asked others if they had found her personal information so someone could "show her the same kind of fear she places in others."

Two days later, on Monday, while local news outlets began to pick up on the Facebook video, it made its way to Twitter, where it would eventually spread across the platform.

It appears to have been first posted on the page of an obscure account, but was ultimately seen and shared by Qasim Rashid, a popular Muslim podcast host and self-described Islamic educator, who posted the video Monday night with a caption detailing the incident as he interpreted it. The tweet would end up with more than 18,000 retweets and go on to receive attention from several other prominent national figures.

But the tweet contained misinformation, indicating that charges had been filed against the girl while "hate crime charges are pending." Charges had not been filed and police had not found any indication that the incident involved any kind of hate crime. Mr. Rashid did not cite a source for that information.

Advertise with us

Mr. Rashid attempted to add context to his tweet the next day, posting an update below the original that said, "Police are ruling out hate crime charges" -- which, according to information from police, isn't accurate either.

Mr. Rashid told the Post-Gazette Thursday that he based his followup tweet -- that hate crimes had been ruled out by police -- on an article from a local TV station, which he linked in the tweet.

Collier Police Chief Craig Campbell said Wednesday that he hadn't seen any of the tweets, but that the public should "allow the police department to complete a fair and accurate investigation before passing judgment on our actions or the actions of the children in the video."

Regardless, Mr. Rashid's tweet took off, and it grabbed the attention of journalist and author Soledad O'Brien on Tuesday afternoon. She referred Mr. Rashid's tweet to her own followers, more than 900,000 in total, writing, "And people ask me why I’m mad all the time. Please spare me the 'this is not America' BS."

Mr. Rashid's tweet continued its trek across Twitter on Wednesday, when CNN contributor Ana Navarro picked it up and tweeted it out with a message to her more than 1 million followers.

Advertise with us

"This is just horrible," Ms. Navarro wrote. "Sad to see someone so young have such hatred in their heart (assuming that girl has a heart). ... I hope the aggressor is prosecuted to full extent of the law."

By this point, users had already started to dox the alleged perpetrator. Doxing is publicly identifying someone's private information with malicious intent, and it was underway by Monday as the video was first making its rounds on Twitter. One user tweeted the girl's Instagram and Snapchat information -- as well as the name of her school -- with the message, "Do your thing Twitter." It has been shared more than 9,000 times.

In response, users tweeted screenshots of the messages they allegedly sent to the girl's accounts. "You were lucky I wasn't there ... if not my foot gonna be on yr face," one wrote. Others asked to fight her. One person ominously noted that "Pittsburgh only a 6 hour drive," while yet another said an effort would be made to get the girl expelled.

The aggressor in the video could not be reached Wednesday.

The doxing didn't stop at the teenage girl. Another user posted the email addresses of Chartiers Valley's principal and assistant principles, asking followers to "take the appropriate steps to make change, email the school heads." When asked about the doxing, Mikaela Duckstein, a spokeswoman for the school district, said the district had seen an increase in phone calls and emails from the public.

Advertise with us

Addressing the consequences of misinformation online, Chief Campbell said that "any speculation without a full investigation does a disservice not only to the victim but to any accused actors."

"The distribution of inaccurate or misleading information not only jeopardizes criminal prosecutions but may serve to incite other criminal action by those that choose to believe incorrect or inaccurate information," Chief Campbell said. "People must recognize that no matter how inflammatory or dramatic a video clip may be, it cannot stand on its own without an accompanying investigation."

This story was originally published with images that are no longer available.