Mt. Lebanon commissioners on Monday approved two controversial decisions — eliminating free garbage collection for some renters and condominium owners and approving another year of sharpshooting whitetail deer.

The commissioners voted 4-0 in favor of an ordinance that eliminates free garbage service for residents who live in commercial structures — defined as those with four or more dwelling units.

No residents or landlords spoke at Monday’s meeting, although dozens recently made their opposition to the plan clear during two contentious public hearings.

Garbage pickup traditionally had been paid for through property and wage taxes, but beginning Jan. 1, 2019, the service will be continued only for those living in residential buildings, such as single-family homes, townhouses and multi-family buildings with three or fewer units. Residents in condominiums or apartments with more than four units will be considered as living in commercial structures.

Advertise with us

About 120 properties and 1,000 units will be affected by the new rules, set to take effect when the municipality’s current five-year contract with Republic Services expires.

In negotiations for a new contract, municipal officials will try to have a clause included that will allow commercial property owners to pay the same rate as the municipality, although they would have a separate contract with the hauler.

On the municipality’s program to cull deer in an effort to reduce vehicle versus deer accidents, Commissioner Kelly Fraasch has long been the only dissenter on the board, and Monday was no exception.

Commissioners voted 3-1 to approve another year of sharpshooting whitetail deer in early 2018.

“[Spending] over $700 per deer to find, shoot, remove and hopefully donate sounds like a crazy way for this municipality to spend its money,” Ms. Fraasch said about the $77,110 contract approved with wildlife management company White Buffalo Inc. to remove as many as 100 deer.

Advertise with us

Now in its third year, the deer management program has consisted of two components: a fall/winter archery hunt and sharpshooting by select hunters later in the winter. The archery hunt is ongoing through Jan. 27 with a holiday break that began Saturday and continues through Dec. 25. The sharpshooting is set for Feb. 1 through March 31.

Voting in favor of the sharpshooting contract were commissioners Dave Brumfield, Steve Silverman and John Bendel. Commissioner Stephen McLean has been excused from attending meetings in November and December due to a health issue, but Mr. Brumfield said Mr. McLean continues to support the program.

The program has had mixed results since it began in late 2015. During that season, 219 deer were culled through archery and sharpshooting. The following year, 91 deer were culled during the same time period, largely due to unseasonably warm temperatures.

The impact on traffic safety has also been dubious — a threefold increase in collisions with deer occurred last year.

Through October of this year, fewer collisions have occurred than last year, but the number is still about 35 percent higher than in 2015. The goal of the program when it was adopted in 2014 was to reduce deer/vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years.

Advertise with us

Resident Bill Hoon, often the only person to comment consistently on the program, said Monday that he and other residents have a plan to feed deer in neighborhoods where sharpshooting and archery aren’t allowed.

“We have decided to go underground,” Mr. Hoon said. “We plan to double the number of people doing that next year … so they will stay out of your kill zone. We’re going to do everything we can.”

But Ms. Fraasch warned that the plan might do more harm than good, by altering the diets of deer and making them friendlier to humans.

“It’s probably the worst thing you can do,” she said. “It’s not fair to the deer.”

Feeding deer also violates an ordinance in Mt. Lebanon, which is punishable with fines.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.