Mt. Lebanon residents turned out in large numbers for a commissioners meeting Tuesday to talk about trash collection and plans for a new shooting range.

The packed meeting was driven largely by a proposed ordinance that would do away with free garbage service for some renters and condominium owners, but it also drew out some residents concerned over the firing range.

For the second time in as many months, commissioners held a public hearing into a proposed solid waste ordinance that would eliminate garbage service to those living in commercial buildings -- which would be classified as four or more dwelling units.

Currently, garbage service is provided by the municipality and paid for through taxes.

Advertise with us

The new ordinance would define residential units as any building or home with three or fewer dwelling units. Townhouses of any size would be considered residential but condominiums and apartment buildings with four or more units would not. There are about 1,000 units in 120 properties that would be considered commercial under the new rules, said assistant manager Ian McMeans.

At last month’s hearing, many landlords spoke out against the change, saying it was unfair to ask renters and condo owners to subsidize garbage service for others. The sentiments Tuesday were much the same.

“These are people who are paying taxes,” said landlord Dave Pirain about his tenants, who would not receive a corresponding reduction in their taxes. “Why we as a group are being segregated, I don’t know.”

Commission Chairman Dave Brumfield said the change is necessary because the municipality has never identified the difference between residential and commercial properties.

Dozens of surrounding municipalities have similar ordinances differentiating between residential and commercial, he said.

Advertise with us

“We have draw the line somewhere,” he said.

If it’s passed, the new ordinance would take effect January 1, 2019, at the same time the municipality is entering into a new garbage service contract. Mr. Brumfield said the municipality is giving residents and property owners more than a year to make other arrangements.

In it’s current contract with Republic, garbage service is provided to 12,500 households in Mt. Lebanon at an annual rate of about $127 each.

Mr. McMeans said the municipality will try to negotiate a clause that will allow commercial property owners to pay the same rate as the municipality.

Mr. Brumfield said the measure may be voted on at the board’s Nov. 27 meeting.

Advertise with us

Commissioners also got an earful from two Pine Avenue residents, concerned about plans to build a new firing range at the Mt. Lebanon Golf Course.

“My primary concern is our children,” said neighbor and parent Eric Arlett, who said he was also concerned about noise, traffic and parking.

“Having it in our backyard is a major concern for us,” agreed parent Jeremy Snyder.

Funding for the $1.5 million firing range was secured earlier this year, though construction isn’t expected to begin until next year.

The new range would replace a 40-year-old range at the public works facility on Cedar Boulevard. It is used for police training, but new regulations require the range to be about 15 feet longer, which is not feasible in the older building, municipal Manager Keith McGill said.

Advertise with us

Residents said they were most concerned about the possibility of other police departments and members of the public using the facility.

While the municipality has discussed allowing regional departments to use the range, Mr. McGill said no formal agreements have been made.

Although there will be no access to the general public, the municipality plans to use the range for recreation department classes in firearm safety and target pistol training. The facility could also be used by the Mt. Lebanon High School Rifle Team, which currently uses a range 40 minutes away in North Strabane.

Resident Saverio Strati Jr. took issue with the idea that the facility could be dangerous.

“People who use these ranges are among the safest people in the world,” said Mr. Strati, who said a NRA-certified expert is always on hand to ensure that safety protocols are followed. “Safety isn’t an issue.”

Advertise with us

Mr. Brumfield said residents can still be heard about the issue before it’s decided. “There is still multiple votes to continue the process,” he said.

Discussion about the range will be continued Dec. 12.

Janice Crompton: jcrompton@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1159 or on Twitter @janicecrompton.