An Allegheny County judge on Monday found a Brentwood man guilty of involuntary manslaughter in the death of his roommate last year following an altercation over missing beer.
Justin Vankirk, 35, will be sentenced on the single misdemeanor count on Feb. 1. Common Pleas Judge Thomas E. Flaherty found Mr. Vankirk not guilty of tampering with evidence.
"It's clear to me Mr. Vankirk did not intend to cause the death of Charles Parker," Judge Flaherty said in rendering his verdict. The judge presided over a three-day non-jury trial last week.
A sentence in the standard range for Mr. Vankirk would be three to 12 months at the Allegheny County Jail.
Police said that Mr. Vankirk got into an argument with his roommate, Mr. Parker, 58, in the early morning hours of Nov. 1, 2016, when Mr. Vankirk accused his longtime friend of stealing his Keystone Ice beer.
Mr. Vankirk admitted to investigators that he punched Mr. Parker three times. But he insisted that when he went to bed that night, Mr. Parker was awake and moving around their Clermont Avenue apartment.
Read More
When Mr. Vankirk awoke the next afternoon to leave for work, he told police Mr. Parker was lying on the floor, and that he believed the man was still passed out from drinking.
When Mr. Vankirk returned to the apartment a couple of hours later, Mr. Parker was in the same position, so Mr. Vankirk called 911. Mr. Parker was pronounced dead at the scene.
In reaching his verdict, Judge Flaherty said he believed Mr. Vankirk acted in a reckless or grossly negligent manner — consistent with involuntary manslaughter.
The prosecution had been seeking a conviction on third-degree murder, which would require the court to find Mr. Vankirk acted with malice.
Instead, Judge Flaherty said, "This event was the result of a drunken altercation between Mr. Vankirk and Mr. Parker.
"I find that recklessness is evident in that Mr. Vankirk struck Mr. Parker three times in the head and, significantly, in the fact that he failed to call for aid."
The judge noted the two had been friends for at least a decade, and that in the morning before the fight, they had gone to Giant Eagle together to buy food for their six cats.
In a surveillance video taken from near borough steps that led from Brownsville Road to the men's apartment, Mr. Vankirk could be seen falling down them about 9:30 p.m. that night, carrying a 12-pack of beer with him.
Judge Flaherty noted that it appeared from the video that two men who helped Mr. Vankirk up may have been the ones who stole his beer, and not Mr. Parker at all.
Mr. Vankirk had been on electronic home monitoring pending trial, and Judge Flaherty ordered that to continue until sentencing.
Defense attorney Lisa Middleman noted that Mr. Vankirk, who has had the same job for 17 years, stopped drinking after Mr. Parker's death and sought in-patient treatment for alcohol abuse.
Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter @PaulaReedWard.



Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.