Justin Vankirk’s defense conceded that he punched his friend and roommate three times, likely leading to bleeding in Charles Parker's brain.

But Lisa Middleman argued Thursday that the prosecution failed to provide any evidence of malice that would make Justin Vankirk guilty of third-degree murder.

Instead, she said, her client ought to be only found guilty of involuntary manslaughter — an unlawful act done in a reckless manner that leads to death.

Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Thomas E. Flaherty, who is presiding over the non-jury trial, will render his verdict Monday afternoon.

Advertise with us

Mr. Vankirk, 35, and Mr. Parker, 58, lived together in an apartment in Brentwood, and according to investigators got into an argument early in the morning on Nov. 1, 2016, when Mr. Vankirk accused his roommate of stealing his Keystone beer.

In a lengthy interview with police, Mr. Vankirk admitted to punching his friend about three times but insisted that when he went to bed that night, Mr. Parker was alive and moving around the apartment.

Assistant District Attorney Matthew Robinowitz conceded that point when he played video surveillance captured nearby of Mr. Parker walking up steps toward Brownsville Road about 2:40 a.m.

Mr. Vankirk told police he woke up later that afternoon, saw Mr. Parker on the floor and believed he was still passed out drunk from the night before. He called 911 about 4:30 p.m. and Mr. Parker was pronounced dead.

Baiyang Xu,.the forensic pathologist who performed Mr. Parker's autopsy, said the victim could have sustained the subdural hematoma — which caused his death — either from the punches or from falling down and striking his head.

Advertise with us

But he also testified that it was possible to live for hours with that kind of injury, and that some of the symptoms associated with it — dizziness, a loss of balance and losing consciousness — mimic the signs of intoxication.

In her closing argument, Ms. Middleman told Judge Flaherty that testimony showed Mr. Parker had a drinking problem and would often pass out. Her client, she continued, would not have been able to tell the difference between a severe injury and severe intoxication.

To find malice in a criminal case where no weapon is used, she continued, the fact-finder must consider the size difference of the defendant and victim; the ferocity and duration of the attack; whether there's provocation; and the manner in which the fists were used.

She told Judge Flaherty that her client did not use a weapon in the assault on Mr. Parker, and that there was no evidence of it being a brutal or vicious attack. Ms. Middleman noted, too, that her client showed visible despair over Mr. Parker’s death at the police station, sobbing with his head in his hands.

“He’s certainly not this evil, vile, uncaring human being,” Ms. Middleman said. “This is not a person who intended to kill someone, or left a person on the floor waiting for him to die.”

Advertise with us

But Mr. Robinowitz told the judge he needed to look at the totality of the circumstances.

Mr. Vankirk was six inches taller and 46 pounds heavier than Mr. Parker and, the prosecutor continued, he was angry at the victim for taking his beer.

“When you beat someone up and you see someone bleeding and leave them to lie there for 12 hours, the sheer number of hours he left him there, I think, rises to the level of malice,” Mr. Robinowitz said. “Common sense says you have to realize that’s more than being drunk.”

Paula Reed Ward: pward@post-gazette.com, 412-263-2620 or on Twitter: @PaulaReedWard.