Seven years after abruptly stopping a sharpshooting program in Mt. Lebanon, commissioners voted Tuesday to start another one, with caveats.
In a 3-2 vote, with commissioners David Brumfield and Kelly Fraasch opposing, the board awarded an $80,750 contract to nonprofit wildlife management organization White Buffalo to augment its ongoing controlled archery hunt with a rifle sharpshooting cull.
But a raft of amendments, issued with a hint of political maneuvering, could reverse the decision. The amendments call for the formation of a municipal team to oversee the sharpshooting program, and for another vote to be held in January to evaluate the plan. That vote will be held after an election that could bring in three new commissioners who could decide to start the whole deer management process over again.
“I’m not comfortable with that,” said commissioner Coleen Vuono, who voted for the program along with commissioners Steve Silverman and John Bendel. “We’ve put a lot of time into this. Are they going to know all that we know?”
The emerging multifaceted deer-management program is intended to reduce deer-vehicle collisions on Mt. Lebanon streets by 50 percent in five years.
In September, commissioners turned down a sharpshooting proposal by the U.S. Department of Agriculture, which lost the cull contract in 2008. Commissioners said they were concerned about the agency’s insistence on shooting from mobile positions as well as elevated platforms.
Read More
White Buffalo president Tony DeNicola, who spoke by phone at the meeting, submitted the only sharpshooting proposal received by commissioners. It calls for daily baiting at predetermined sites, use of sound-suppressed .223-caliber or .22-caliber rifles and shooting during day or night from elevated platforms at a steep angle of trajectory. The sharpshooting would occur from Feb. 1 to March 31, 2016.
White Buffalo’s archery program is considered a hunt, which observes state laws and regulations, elements of fair chase and requires no special permitting by the state Game Commission.
The sharpshooting plan is a cull that includes practices not permitted in a hunt, such as baiting, big-game shooting at night and the elimination of fair chase practices to kill many deer. For the cull to occur, it would require the Game Commission to issue a political subdivision permit, similar to the special permit approved early this year for a failed trap-and-shoot management program.
For program management, communication, planning, public education and Game Commission permitting, White Buffalo estimated the cost to be $13,080. Mr. DeNicola has said the commission’s management goal could be achieved with the elimination of 150 deer. At an approximate cost of $451 per deer, the actual cull was estimated to cost $67,670.
A robust public comment session, civil by past Mt. Lebanon standards, included residents who opposed and supported sharpshooting.
“Deer are an important host for ticks that carry Lyme disease. In Allegheny County there were 850 cases last year, and [about 200] cases the year before,” said Michalina Pendzich of Longuevue Drive, citing research conducted in part by Tom Simmons, a biology professor at Indiana University of Pennsylvania. “Archery alone will not adequately reduce the size of the deer herd. I urge [commissioners] to vote to include sharpshooting as part of our deer management program.”
Jan Seybold of Academy Avenue told commissioners she was already “incensed” about the archery hunt.
“The state Game Commission says you need a 50-yard safety zone for archery,” she said. “Most of the houses in Mt. Lebanon are 20 feet from each other. I don’t even know how you do this. There is pure evil in what you’re doing.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.