Archers are expected to climb into tree stands on several private properties late next week to begin a controlled deer cull in Mt. Lebanon.

Mt. Lebanon commissioners approved the cull in a 4-1 vote late Tuesday, marking a win for supporters of a controlled hunt. But backers of nonlethal deer control also claimed victory, as did those who want sharpshooters to kill the deer.

But one deer expert says a multifaceted approach may be the only solution.

At the end of a meeting packed with vocal spectators that lasted until after 11:30 p.m., the board approved a controlled archery hunt organized by wildlife management group White Buffalo. Project manager Jody Maddock said the hunt is ready to begin Sept. 19 on 18 “property groups,” or clusters of properties. Tree stands have been hung mostly on private properties, but six public spaces will be included: the conservation district, the golf course, the public works area, and McNeilly, Twin Hills and Robb Hollow parks.

Advertise with us

Of 75 archers who applied to participate, 11 were chosen. The locations of participating private properties and identities of hunt managers and hunters will be kept confidential. Hunting will continue intermittently through the last week of January.

Commissioners asked Mr. Maddock to limit park hunts to Mondays through Fridays, and they agreed to pay White Buffalo $15,460 to organize and execute the hunt.

Commissioners also moved toward a nonlethal control method that would require ending the controlled hunt they had just approved. The board will get more information about an experimental sterilization or contraception program suggested by the Humane Society of the United States.

The Humane Society’s Pennsylvania director, Kristen Tullo, proposed that Mt. Lebanon become the staging ground for a five-year experiment to determine whether sterilization or contraception without prior removal of some deer could result in a sustained reduction of deer density. Sterilization and contraception would require a special Game Commission permit; none has ever been approved.

Commissioners also voted to request proposals from wildlife sharpshooter groups but refused a U.S. Department of Agriculture proposal after cull specialists said they could not reach management goals by shooting only from tree stands, as preferred by commissioners. Commissioners Fraasch and David Brumfield voted against seeking sharpshooters.

Advertise with us

Mt. Lebanon wants to reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years. In a phone interview Wednesday, White Buffalo president Tony DeNicola said the best way to get there is through a merger of lethal and nonlethal means.

Despite his oversight of the archery program, Mr. DeNicola said Mt. Lebanon’s best bet would be to combine an ongoing controlled hunt with a surgical sterilization program.

“A multi-pronged approach, most of the time, is the most efficient way to solve the problem,” he said. “The difficulty is trying to find the politics that could mesh a lethal and nonlethal process. I can almost guarantee it would work in three years.”

John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.