Mt. Lebanon will have its venison and eat it, too. At last night’s marathon meeting of Mt. Lebanon commissioners, the board voted to approve a planned archery deer hunt, but also showed interest in a deer sterilization experiment that would end the hunt. Commissioners rejected a proposal from the U.S. Department of Agriculture to cull deer, but is inviting proposals from other sharpshooters.
With some 40 resident speakers the meeting ended after 11:30 p.m. By a vote of 4 to 1, the board approved a controlled archery hunt organized by White Buffalo. During a discussion period prior to the vote, project manager Jody Maddock said the hunt was ready to begin with 18 “property groups,” or clusters of properties, on which to hunt. Of 75 archers who applied to participate, 11 were chosen — six currently approved, one pending approval and four on a waiting list.
The hunt is to begin Sept. 19 and continue through the last week of January. The archers will not hunt during weeks when state regulations require archery deer hunters to wear fluorescent orange. Most of the hunting will occur on private property with the permission of the owners and their neighbors. Six public spaces will be included: the conservation district, the golf course, the public works area, and McNeilly, Robb Hollow and Twin Hills parks.
“There will be some hunting in some of the parks,” Mr. Maddock said. “It will be from tree stands and only members of police departments who were among the best of the best hunters chosen will hunt there. It’s not for safety — I don’t believe there is a safety issue — but it’s for the community's comfort.”
Commissioners asked Mr. Maddock to limit park hunts to Mondays through Fridays. The cost to the municipality will be about $15,000.
“I’ve been very impressed with the support of the residents for this program,” Mr. Maddock said.
Read More
Commissioners passed 3 to 2 an initiative to request proposals from wildlife sharpshooter groups, but refused a USDA proposal because cull specialists said they could not effectively shoot exclusively from tree stands.
Todd Puckett, USDA Wildlife Services district director, said a three-person team using rifles with night-vision optics would shoot from elevated platforms on trucks into hillside backstops.
“We wouldn’t be able to achieve our goal shooting only from tree stands,” he said.
Asked about commission concerns that ended a previous Wildlife Services cull in 2007 and 2008, specialist Amy Hess said she was there the night that one wounded deer ran into another yard before dying.
“There were three of us. We looked for a long time for that deer and just couldn’t find it,” she said.
“Things like that are going to occur in any type of hunting situation,” Mr. Puckett said.
Kristen Tullo, Pennsylvania director of the Humane Society of the United States, said an experiment to surgically sterilize deer could be conducted in Mt. Lebanon.
Commissioners voted 3 to 2 in favor of accepting a Humane Society proposal for program, which would involved sterilization, immunocontraception or both. The five-year experiment would attempt to determine if sterilization or contraception without prior removal of some deer could result in a sustained reduction of deer density. The project would require other deer control programs to end, Mt. Lebanon commissioners’ stated goal is to reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years.
Via telephone, Humane Society biologist Stephanie Boyles Griffin said similar experiments have showed promise. The new element in the proposal is the possibility that the experiment could be funded by an outside group. The project, which could cost about $200,000, could be financed, at least in part, by the Dietrich W. Botstiber Foundation, known for financing programs to prevent cruelty to people and animals. Earlier on Tuesday, a foundation spokeswoman confirmed the group hoped to provide assistance for the sterilization plan. Ms. Boyles Griffin said she hoped the foundation would pick up 100 percent of the cost.
The archery program is a hunt that does not require special permitting from the state Game Commission. Sharpshooting over bait requires Game Commission approval and has been allowed in many cases, including in Mt. Lebanon. Deer sterilization and contraception would require a special Game Commission permit. No such permission has ever been approved.
John Hayes: 412-263-1991, jhayes@post-gazette.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.