Duke Lake, a popular fishing, swimming and boating venue in Ryerson Station State Park for generations of Greene County residents, was drained 10 years ago after subsidence from an ongoing mining operation cracked the dam that held back its waters. Now, the state says the lake will stay dry, probably forever.
Cindy Adams Dunn, the state Department of Conservation and Natural Resources secretary, visited the park in western Greene County on Friday to announce that plans to rebuild the dam and refill the 62-acre lake by 2017 have been abandoned because the ground around the dam and lake continues to shift and subside.
“Greene County has lost a significant recreational resource when the lake was drawn down, and we know many residents and community members will be disappointed that replacement of the dam is currently not possible with an unstable foundation,” Ms. Dunn said, citing a new state-sponsored study that once again laid the blame for the 2005 dam damage on subsidence caused by Consol Energy’s Bailey longwall mine.
According to the study, new mining planned over the next four years adjacent to the 1,164-acre park could cause even more earth movement and instability around the dam as well as diminish stream water flows needed to fill and replenish the lake.
Ms. Dunn said the state will seek input from a new Duke Lake task force and at public meetings in the fall and look to “re-envision” the only state park in Greene County with new recreational attractions and amenities.
But as backhoes continued to scrape sediment from the dried lake bed Friday, local residents, public officials and park employees expressed anger, sadness and grief over the DCNR’s decision not to fix the dam and fill the lake, described by Greene County Commissioner Blair Zimmerman as “the onetime jewel of the western part of our county.”
“I feel like I’ve been kicked in the stomach,” said Mr. Zimmerman, who once fished the lake. “Ryerson is all about Duke Lake. That’s why people came here. There’s going to be a lot of angry people, but eventually, I hope that when all is said and done, something positive will come of this.”
“I’m emotional about this, I admit. I’m in disbelief and there’s a real sense of disappointment,” said Jeffrey Anna, western regional manager for DCNR’s Bureau of Parks and Ryerson’s superintendent from 1994 through 1999. “I think we’re at the beginning of a long process to make this an exceptional park again.”
State Rep. Pam Snyder, D-Greene, said Duke Lake was a focal point for county residents, especially those who fished. She said building a smaller fishing lake is an option that should be explored.
“It’s sad that we can’t rebuild the dam,” Ms. Snyder said. “But I think there is a strong commitment by the DCNR to enhance the park’s features and, in the long term, make it an important, viable asset for the community.”
After cracks appeared in the 45-year-old Duke Lake Dam in April 2005, the lake was drained and three months later the dam was breached by DCNR for safety reasons. In February 2010, a state investigation determined that the 515-foot-long concrete dam was damaged due to subsidence caused by Consol Energy’s Bailey longwall coal mine.
In April 2013, the DCNR and Consol reached a settlement in which the company admitted no fault but paid $36 million to replace the dam. Some of that money will be used to build new park facilities, Ms. Dunn said.
Don Hopey: dhopey@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.