With just six deer killed since the first shots were fired in the Mt. Lebanon deer cull, the program will not reach commissioners’ goal of significantly reducing the whitetail population by March 31, according to the contractor hired to kill the deer.

“There’s no way at this point we could take enough to make a difference,” said Merlin Benner of Wildlife Specialists. “I would say over 100 would have made an impact toward their goals. Even 75 would have made an impact on the population.”

After years of debate over deer density, Mt. Lebanon commissioners agreed to hire the Tioga County company to bait, trap and kill enough deer to reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years. Wildlife Specialists is paid $500 per deer up to $75,000.

But Mr. Benner said delays in the permitting process resulted in the cull starting after snow had melted, reducing the effectiveness of the bait. Further contributing to the low success rates were five acts of attempted obstruction, which were reported to Mt. Lebanon police. Photos show numerous additional acts of trespass near the sites, which could have kept deer away.

Advertise with us

No equipment was permanently damaged and no arrests have been made. Deputy Chief Aaron Lauth confirmed the attempts at obstruction, which include a feeder removed from a corral and thrown down a hill, balls of foul-smelling fabric tossed into corrals and a stick wedged to prevent a remote-control gate from closing. Penalties, he said, could range from Game Commission violations to criminal mischief, a third-degree felony with a fine of up to $5,000.

Game Commission biologist and deer expert Jeannine Fleegle, who observed the culling, said Wildlife Specialists “followed the conditions of the permit to the letter,” and that deer appeared calm and “waiting” in the corral after the gate was closed.

But the warming weather, she said, has become a deterrent to the corral trap process.

“Look outside. The weather’s breaking — it’s spring,” said Ms. Fleegle. “The deer aren’t stressed, they’re eating what’s beginning to bloom now and they don’t need to go into a trap to eat. It’s going to be more and more difficult to capture deer.”

Mr. Benner said it’s hard to gauge how much money the company may have lost because of the late start and obstruction at the cull sites.

Advertise with us

“We’ve not broken even on this. Definitely not,” he said.

The plan as of Thursday was to continue through March 31. That deadline was established by municipal commissioners; the Game Commission permit authorizes culling activities to continue through Sept. 31. Mr. Benner said he’d consider continuing the cull if he was allowed to use sharpshooting, which he and the Game Commission had originally recommended as the best way to quickly remove the deer.

“But I don’t think there’s the political will to do it,” he said. “I’ve been involved in wildlife management for 25 years now. I had a very good idea of the social pressures we’d find here, but we felt that this new technique approved for the first time by the Game Commission would open up new options. To some extent our involvement was an investment in the new technology.”

Tom Fazi, spokesman for the Game Commision’s southwest district, says the bait, trap and kill corral method continues to seem viable despite the unsuccessful Mt. Lebanon experiment, and may have applications elsewhere in the state.

“I think this process and scale would have worked just fine if they could have started a little earlier and if the [municipality] had prepared a little more in the way of getting out public information ahead of time,” said Mr. Fazi.

Advertise with us

Anti-cull activists aren’t so sure.

“We thought the [deer] numbers were inflated to begin with,” said Kathy Poulton of Arrowood Drive, near Robb Hollow Park. “I think he’s using obstruction as an excuse. Maybe the deer they expected to see aren’t there.”

Ms. Poulton said she’s independent of the disparate coalition of groups and individuals who oppose the cull. But many have mistrusted the municipality’s deer-density statistics, she said, and strong unity has emerged in opposing the cull’s method and scale.

“That’s why it’s been so polarizing,” she said. “That’s why people are in such an uproar. It’s kindred spirits who, when they found out the method, were outraged.”