After dark on March 9, the first night of the Mt. Lebanon deer cull, about 15 animal rights activists gathered in the Bird Park parking lot. They carried no signs or posters. They were there to do something, anything, to stop what they called a “slaughter.”

“I’m here because Mt. Lebanon has options. There are other places across the country that have pursued other methods of deer removal that don’t involve killing,” said Chris Bangs of Squirrel Hill. “This night doesn’t have to end with deer being killed.”

Volunteer animal rights organizer Leila Sleiman said they had come to document a culling on video and post it for the world to see.

Sarah Scholl was more blunt in her intentions.

Advertise with us

“Our objective is to not have the deer trapped in corrals,” she said. “Make noise — I wouldn’t consider that obstructing. We’re all so concerned about this matter.”

She’s not alone. Dozens of animal rights activists from Mt. Lebanon and beyond have demonstrated inside and outside of the Mt. Lebanon municipal building, and an anti-cull petition posted on the Internet drew virtual signatures from around the country.

Several Pittsburgh-area communities routinely kill white-tailed deer to thin problem herds. But none has experienced the number of protesters or intensity of opposition that’s going on now in Mt. Lebanon.

Fox Chapel, Upper St. Clair, the Allegheny County Park Department and others routinely reduce deer density through lethal means — volunteer archery groups or police sharpshooters discreetly kill a pre-determined number of does to keep the population in check.

Unchecked, each deer eats a ton of browse each year and the population doubles every two years, according to Chris Rosenberry, a biologist and head of the state Game Commission’s deer management team.

Advertise with us

In 2005, with deer-human conflicts growing in Mt. Lebanon, the Game Commission approved a taxpayer-funded program in which sharpshooters from the U.S. Department of Agriculture, armed with noise-suppressed rifles, killed nearly 250 deer in two years.

The community’s deer problem was exacerbated, however, when in 2008 municipal commissioners prematurely ended the program after a gun-shot deer died in a resident’s yard, and another resident claimed to have heard a shot.

Since 2008, there has been no stewardship of Mt. Lebanon’s wild places with the exception of a ban on deer feeding, which has not been enforced. The spike in deer density is reflected in increased complaints about negative deer-human contacts and municipal records showing a spike in deer-vehicle collisions from 23 in 2011, to 49 in 2012, and 43 in 2013.

“The community is telling us that the problem is too many deer now,” said Mr. Rosenberry, shortly after Mt. Lebanon’s plan was approved in February. “In some way, some of the animals have to come out of the population.”

Mt. Lebanon commissioners agreed to pay Wildlife Specialists of Tioga County $500 per deer up to $75,000 per year to trap and kill as many as 150 deer.

Advertise with us

Ms. Sleiman said she and other activists are uncomfortable with the killing of any animal. But the scale and method of this cull, she said, have outraged Mt. Lebanon animal lovers and attracted outside opposition.

“There’s got to be a better way,” said Ms. Sleiman. “For animal lovers, this is just too much. It’s unacceptable.”

Seeking a ‘palatable answer’

“I’m an animal lover,” said Jim Bonner, executive director of the Western Pennsylvania Audubon Society. “I feel for them, I understand their concerns about what’s happening in Mt. Lebanon. It’s tough to find a palatable answer that meets everyone’s needs.”

Mr. Bonner said Audubon takes an effective, time-honored conservation approach to managing deer at the group’s Western Pennsylvania headquarters on the 134-acre Beechwood Farms Nature Reserve in Fox Chapel.

Advertise with us

“We work in concert with the police and an approved archery group,” he said. “We look at it as the responsible way of managing wildlife on our property.”

Fox Chapel police use noise-suppressed rifles to kill deer in the municipality and on Audubon property, and specific numbers of does are taken in controlled hunts by vetted archers during deer seasons.

Non-lethal measures, he suggested, range from impractical to impossible.

“Hysterectomy is not an easy thing to do on deer. Catch and release — too many die from stress, there’s the danger of spreading diseases and the expense is high,” he said.

“Sterility or contraceptive drugs require yearly booster shots, which you can’t do on wild deer. Our research says it doesn’t necessarily reduce the number of deer. And anyway, those drugs are not approved for use [in the wild] anywhere in the country.”

Advertise with us

Keeping the deer population in check, said Mr. Bonner, has enabled Beechwood Farms Nature Reserve to maintain a wide variety of plants and birds. “It’s trying to balance nature in an unbalanced environment,” he said.

Carnegie Museum of Natural History’s Powdermill Nature Preserve in Westmoreland County is nationally famous for its bird-banding program. Director John Wenzel said deer are managed on the 2,000-acre property by encouraging independent hunting.

“Since the 1970s or 1980s, deer are the primary negative influence on Eastern forests,” he said. “In urban parks with no management program, there can be such an astronomical number of deer that the parks can’t support them.”

Without predators to provide ecological balance, suburbs are not natural environments and require human stewardship, he said. When people see a frequent abundance of deer on their properties, it’s a sign that something’s wrong.

“These animals are beautiful and everybody loves to see them. But they don’t want to see you,” said Mr. Wenzel. “The reason deer are walking through their yards and getting hit on the road — they’re desperate, they’re looking for food.”

Advertise with us

Overpopulation, he said, is a terrible thing.

“People think they’re helping the deer, but they’re hurting every animal that loses its habitat to deer, and they’re really hurting the deer themselves by allowing them to overpopulate.”

The Western Pennsylvania Conservancy owns some 12,000 acres including Bear Run Nature Reserve, the Fayette County home of Frank Lloyd Wright’s world-famous Fallingwater. Andy Zadnik, the conservancy’s land stewardship manager, said hunting is the primary, practical way to manage wildlife on conservancy lands.

“We encourage hunting in the interest of keeping our forests healthy,” he said. “An overpopulation of deer can have adverse impacts on forest regeneration and understory plant communities, and that impacts many other species.”

Controlling the deer, suggested Mr. Zadnik, controls the habitat needed by other species.

Advertise with us

The conservancy’s Wolf Creek Narrows near Slippery Rock, Butler County, is known for its wildflower display.

“If there were too many deer on that property, the 200 acres of flowers would be gone,” he said.

Wildlife management isn’t a problem at Pittsburgh Zoo and PPG Aquarium, or its fenced 724-acre African elephant sanctuary in Somerset County. But biologist and zoo curator Henry Kacprzyk said deer are herbivores that can have negative impacts on other wildlife. Lethal means, he said, can be an appropriate management tool.

“What happened in Mt. Lebanon, I would classify as mismanagement,” he said. “They got themselves into this situation. There has to be effective deer management, otherwise you get so many that problems associated with them get too big to handle. You have to step away, look at the big picture and consider a more encompassing approach, a real scientific method of deer control.”