A standing-room crowd of more than 100 people packed the Mt. Lebanon Commission meeting Tuesday night and more than 40 of them signed up for the right to have five minutes to voice their views on a controversial deer cull that has divided the South Hills community.
It appeared the majority of those in attendance were opposed to the plan to cull as many as 150 white-tailed deer by month’s end. Many of those in attendance held signs from an earlier rain-soaked protest outside the Municipal Building on Washington Road.
“Our deer do not deserve the violent, torturous death they will face,” one woman told the commissioners, saying the cull was a “senseless slaughter. Blood is on your hands. Where is your compassion?”
But a member of the Lebo Residents for Effective Deer Management voiced her support of the cull and said the group had 1,400 signatures of residents on a petition supporting the cull, saying the overpopulation of deer was a public safety hazard and a nuisance.
Before taking comments, commission Chairman John Bendel acknowledged there are strong views on both sides of the decision, which he and three of his four fellow commissioners supported. Breaking from tradition, the commission would not allow nonresidents to speak, a decision that upset many in the crowd, especially one man who was escorted from the meeting by a police officer.
“We understand there are residents and others who will never approve of a lethal way to control the deer population,” he said before citizen comments were heard. “We are moving forward with the plan that we think is in the best interest of the public.”
Read More
Mt. Lebanon was recently issued a Pennsylvania Game Commission permit to cull as many as 150 deer by March 31. Wildlife Specialists of Wellsboro, Tioga County, was contracted to receive $500 per deer up to $75,000 per year with a goal of removing enough deer to reduce deer-vehicle collisions by 50 percent in five years.
The permit stipulates that no more than six deer at a time may be lured into baited corral traps. A gate will close and Wildlife Specialists employees will shoot the deer from elevated platforms. The venison will be donated to food banks.
Wildlife Specialists owner Merlin Benner said Tuesday that the commission had approved his request to increase to five from two the number of employees participating in setup and shooting deer. Mr. Benner was in the woods in Mt. Lebanon for the first shoot Monday night, but no deer were killed.
He and his team planned to be out again Tuesday night in one or more of the five approved cull sites that could have as many as eight corrals. He asked the Game Commission to allow him to use more people so he could work faster and more efficiently.
Contractors from Wildlife Specialists had equipment set up and were in position Monday night at Robb Hollow Park to begin the controversial cull of white-tailed deer. But Mr. Benner and his staff left the Robb Hollow cull site empty-handed.
Prior to the commission meeting, nearly 40 protesters faced Washington Road, most holding homemade signs and umbrellas to fight off a steady rain in a demonstration that began at 5:30 p.m., 2½ hours preceding a Mt. Lebanon meeting. Within an hour, the rain had driven half of them out of the elements.
The protesters cheered when vehicles driving by on Mt. Lebanon's main thoroughfare honked horns in support.
Several held a large banner that read “Mt. Lebanon Commissioners Murderers.” Another sign quoted Genesis from the Bible about the beauty of all living things. One called the cull “Barbaric.”
A spokeswoman for the protesters, Leila Sleiman, an animal rights activist, claimed there is no deer problem in Mt. Lebanon.
“This is a solution looking for a problem,” she said as rain bounced off her clear plastic umbrella. “Some people in Mt. Lebanon have had no contact with a deer.”
She called the cull “irresponsible and reprehensible.”
On Monday evening, demonstrators opposing the cull gathered in the early evening at Bird Park but didn’t fan out to culling sites as planned. While some said their intention was to “make noise” to disrupt the cull, Ms. Sleiman said the goal was to act as “citizen monitors.”





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.