Investigators are trying to determine how coke-oven gas ignited Wednesday morning inside a section of U.S. Steel Corp.'s mammoth coke manufacturing plant in Clairton, triggering an explosion so powerful that it blew out concrete-block walls, bent heavy steel beams and injured 20 workers, some critically.

"That's what the focus will be. It was coke-oven gas. They did have a leak of it, and it sought out an ignition source, and there was an explosion," said Robert A. Full, Allegheny County's emergency management chief.

Several workers at the Clairton Plant had been standing within "footsteps" of the explosion and were enveloped by a fireball, yet survived, Chief Full said.

"By the grace of God, nobody's dead," he told reporters outside the plant's main gate as workers headed for home at the end of their shift at 3 p.m. "It's a miracle no one was killed outright by the blast."

Advertise with us

Despite the blast's sheer power, which shook the plant, it went largely unnoticed by the facility's residential neighbors along State Street save for a billowing black cloud that quickly dissipated and a temporary increase in the stench of pungent chemicals.

That low-level impact likely occurred because the blast wave headed toward the Monongahela River instead of in the opposite direction toward the rest of the plant, Chief Full said.

Two federal agencies, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration and the Bureau of Alcohol, Tobacco, Firearms and Explosives, were on hand to figure out what happened. Although the ATF usually investigates crimes, the agency also lends its expertise to OSHA in determining the causes of industrial accidents.

"They have resources you can't believe," Chief Full said.

Something ignited the highly flammable coke-oven gas inside a section of the plant known as "B battery," Chief Full said, but how the gas leaked and what sparked it remain unclear. Chief Full said it may take days to understand what caused the explosion.

Advertise with us

"There are a lot of interviews to be conducted," he said.

In a statement, U.S. Steel pledged to work with investigators.

"Our thoughts are with the individuals who were injured as well as their families," according to the statement. "Safety is a core value for our company and a full investigation into the cause of the incident is under way. We will be cooperating fully with the agencies involved in the investigation process as well as involved contractors."

The explosion forced the shutdown of the battery, one of nine operational batteries at the plant, but the rest of the facility was functioning normally.

The Clairton Plant, sprawling over 392 acres, sits hard on the Monongahela River's west bank about 20 miles south of Pittsburgh. U.S. Steel says the coking operation is the nation's largest, producing about 4.7 million tons of the material each year.

Advertise with us

Coke is a key ingredient in the steel-making process. At the plant, coal is loaded from above into a furnace called a coke oven. It is heated to about 2,000 degrees Celsius for several hours, driving out the impurities.

What's left is coke. A ram pushes the coke out of the oven through a side door and into a car, and the process begins anew.

A row of the ovens is called a battery, and the explosion occurred at the plant's largest -- dubbed "B battery" -- which has 75 ovens. The battery looks something like a loaf of sliced bread, with each slice representing an individual oven, according to Michael Wright, director of health, safety and environment for the United Steelworkers.

A coke plant contains any number of dangerous compounds and byproducts. Among them is the toxic and highly flammable oven gas created during the heating process. That gas is recycled into the flues that fire the battery.

"What you've got is that big loaf of bread, but you've also got a lot of piping which carries this stuff around. And if there is a breach of the piping in some way and you get a release, and the release finds a source of ignition, then you can have an explosion," Mr. Wright said.

Advertise with us

"And something like that is almost certainly what happened, but the exact scenario we don't know, and we won't know for some time."

Tracing a leak or an ignition source might not be easy.

"There's all kinds of ways gas could escape," Mr. Wright said. As for the ignition source, "It could be anything. It could be a spark. It could be pieces of metal rubbing together."

Mr. Wright said it was too early to determine whether there was any common thread linking Wednesday's explosion and one last year that killed Nicholas Revetta, 32, of Clairton, and injured another in a different area of the plant.

"Just about the only common factor is that initial reports are often wrong. So we try real hard not to jump to conclusions," Mr. Wright said.

Advertise with us

Long after the injured workers were rushed to hospitals, the fire continued to burn as firefighters and plant safety workers struggled throughout the day to suppress it with steam and nitrogen.

While acknowledging that he is not an expert on the mechanics of coke ovens, Chief Full said the gas had to be turned off slowly, a bit at a time, while nitrogen was pumped back into the gas line. Officials finally had the fire out at about 2:30 p.m.

Chief Full said it had been a normal workday at the plant in the moments leading up to the explosion. Routine maintenance was being performed on the battery when the explosion occurred at 9:37 a.m. A total of 20 people were injured, but three were treated on site and released from the plant's medical facility.

Of the injured, 14 were company employees and six were contractors. Businesses that have contracts with U.S. Steel have facilities on the plant premises. Five of the injured union workers are members of Steamfitters Local 449.

When the blast went off, it released a massive fireball. Workers' flame-resistant clothing burned, Chief Full said. A black cloud -- so dark that a county air quality inspector initially thought coal dust caused the explosion -- went into the air.

Advertise with us

When the explosion occurred, the inspector was in a trailer about a quarter mile from the blast, said Jim Thompson, manager of the Allegheny County Air Quality Program.

"He said the windows of the trailer were rumbling pretty good when the explosion happened," Mr. Thompson said. "He described it as a cannon going off."

After the explosion, dozens of ambulances and the county's mass casualty response team arrived to transport the injured. The patients were taken to UPMC Mercy, UPMC Presbyterian, UPMC McKeesport, Jefferson Regional Medical Center and West Penn's burn unit, which received three workers, two of them in critical condition. One patient was flown by helicopter.

Dr. Larry Jones, director of the burn unit at West Penn Hospital, said he expected the three patients there to survive. But he said the two in critical condition, both men in their mid-50s, have chemical burns in their airways that complicate their cases.

One of those men has burns over 30 percent of his body; the other has burns up to 10 percent. The third worker, a man in his mid-40s, was in serious condition with burns over 10 percent to 12 percent of his body and an ankle fracture.

Advertise with us

All have burns to the neck, head, face and hands, Dr. Jones said.

Family members were at the hospital but they didn't want to talk to reporters, a spokeswoman said.

Dr. Jones said medics told him that the men with airway injuries might have inhaled sulfuric acid, which would make their injuries much more severe -- particularly if the injuries affect their lungs. Dr. Jones said doctors believe their injuries were limited to their upper airways.

Six victims were taken by ambulance to Mercy. Doctors said all the men were covered in black soot when they arrived about 10:30 a.m. and had to be cleaned before they were treated.

One of the victims was treated for a soot-related injury and released.

Advertise with us

The other five remain at the hospital. One was in critical condition because of an inhalation injury caused by heat, Dr. Alain Corcos said. The other four were in serious condition.

Dr. Corcos said all the victims, men with ages ranging from their 20s to 50s, had second- and third-degree burns caused by flames.

He said their burns ranged from 15 percent to 40 percent of their bodies. Despite the severity of their injuries, Dr. Corcos said, doctors "expect them to do well."

"We treat patients of this severity all the time," he said.

A decontamination facility was set up at UPMC McKeesport, where the injured workers were treated initially before being sent to other hospitals, according to UPMC spokeswoman Gloria Kreps.

Advertise with us

Chief Full said initial reports indicated some workers might be trapped inside the battery, but he said the company later determined that everyone was accounted for.

The blast was contained inside the battery and no one in nearby Clairton or in the borough of Lincoln, across the river from the coke works, was in any danger. No buildings were evacuated.

County health department officials sought to reassure the public that the explosion caused no long-lasting ill effects.

"The one thing probably worth noting is that our monitors have not shown any increased pollution in the area due to the explosion. In fact, they're just reading as they normally would," Mr. Thompson said.

Health inspectors routinely monitor emissions at both the Clairton works and the Shenango Inc. coke plant on Neville Island.

Advertise with us

Mr. Thompson said despite the two explosions in the past year at the plant, he called the event "fairly rare" and said they are the only ones of which he is aware in the past eight years or so.

Chief Full said the county has responded over the years to many steel mill accidents.

"I know that this business is very dangerous," he said.