James Chabalie comes from a “firefighting family.”

His grandfather and great-grandfather were members of the Cecil Township Volunteer Fire Department in Washington County, where he recalled spending many days exploring the equipment and marveling at the fire trucks. 

Mr. Chabalie, 37, also saw his grandfather leaving in the middle of dinners or holiday events. Losing sleep. Cutting short personal time to respond to a call for help.  

But none of that deterred him when he decided to join the department in 2004 as a junior member, working toward the day he, too, could fight fires and help people in their greatest moments of need. 

Advertise with us

“Being a firefighter is something honorable that people can look up to because you are providing that service to your community and to others,” said Mr. Chabalie, now captain of the Elizabeth Township Fire Department, Station 140. “I always kind of liked the idea of being someone that people can rely on in their time of need.”

But great risk doesn’t always result in great reward, and for volunteer firefighters, the challenges can often outweigh the benefits. 

In Allegheny County, more than 90% of fire departments are made up entirely of volunteers. And unlike firefighters in the Pittsburgh Bureau of Fire — who make between $23.80 and $37.89 an hour, depending on rank and years of service — volunteers receive no salary, no guaranteed stipends and no overtime.

Facing limited resources, increased training requirements and an aging workforce, volunteer fire departments are stretched thin as their memberships continue to shrink. 

“If you lose six guys in one day, because all of them are at work or all of them are on vacation or whatever it might be, it's kind of scary to think what kind of help somebody is going to get whenever they call 911,” said Roman Gardner, an engineer, firefighter and EMT for Elizabeth Township.

Advertise with us
Jim Chabalie, captain at Elizabeth Township Fire Department, Station 140, displays saws capable of cutting through roofing material, concrete, wood and steel while walking through the station in Elizabeth Township on Friday. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

And without the predictability of knowing who will respond to a fire and with what resources, county leaders are warning of the consequences of this model after at least nine fire deaths in the county this year. 

"The volunteer fire services are at a critical mass at this point," Allegheny County Council President Pat Catena told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV earlier this year. "We just don't have enough volunteers."

Allegheny County Emergency Services highlighted the need for donations, which play a large part in keeping the fire departments running, on Giving Tuesday — when leaders called on residents to support their local departments. 

More than putting out fires

Mr. Gardner, 21, said his interest in firefighting began when he was about 4, watching fire trucks go by.

“I remember them pulling out onto Route 48 in Elizabeth and I was like, ‘Oh, Mom, I want to do that,’ and at that age, my mom was like, ‘Oh, whatever. You’re a little kid, every little kid wants to be a fireman.’ But I just never really grew out of it,” he said.

Advertise with us

At 14, Mr. Gardner became a junior member of the Elizabeth Township Fire Department, and he was enrolled in entry level firefighting courses through the Allegheny County Fire Academy, paid for by the fire department, the following year.

Although Pennsylvania doesn’t have state-mandated training requirements for volunteer firefighters, most local fire departments, including Elizabeth Township, require members to participate in training through the academy, which offers a basic training course that can take around 200 hours to complete.

The program teaches everything from handling basic equipment to using hose lines and ladders during fires.

For Mr. Gardner, who doesn’t come from a firefighter family, the level of commitment required came as a shock. 

“I didn't have a very accurate representation in my head of what that would entail,” he said. “I kind of figured that you'd have to go to school for it, and you'd have to actually learn about it, but it was a lot more than just, hey, let's spray some water on it.” 

Advertise with us

Fire chiefs across the county say the time commitment to become a certified firefighter is partly why some hesitate to take on the role. 

“People are working multiple jobs, they're having different shifts that they're working, or family commitments they have to tend to,” Mr. Chabalie said. “So it's not as easy as it used to be to dedicate that time to the fire department, especially with the rising training standards that we try to meet.”

Mr. Chabalie is among those juggling several roles.

He works full time as a computer-aided dispatch technician for Allegheny County, part time as a 911 dispatcher in Washington County, and he also volunteers for the Fallowfield Township Fire Department.

Volunteer firefighters are also asked to participate in fundraising — which departments rely on for equipment maintenance and replacements. 

Advertise with us

“People do want to volunteer, but they want to go fight fires,” said Matthew Austin, chief of the Logan Ferry Heights Volunteer Fire Department in Plum. “We spend a lot of time on fundraising, which might not be appealing to a younger generation to come and cook fish sandwiches.”

Jim Chabalie, captain at Elizabeth Township Fire Department, Station 140, has a full-time job, part-time job and another volunteer job, in addition to his work with the department. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Several leaders of volunteer departments in Allegheny County told the Post-Gazette that the time commitment combined with little to no pay deters many young people, leaving them with an aging workforce that’s shrinking.

“There's definitely a dwindling number of volunteers. We not only struggle to get people in the door, but when we do get them to join, once they see the commitments involved, they don't always stick around very long,” Mr. Chabalie said.

And it’s not just an Allegheny County problem — it’s statewide.

According to the Office of the State Fire Commissioner, Pennsylvania is down to about 38,000 volunteers compared to more than 300,000 in the 1970s, KDKA reported. 

Advertise with us

“Overall, the trend for the last several decades has been a steady decline in active volunteers and an increase in average age among those who remain,” OSFC spokesman Andrew DeBrunner told the Post-Gazette.

He also identified training requirements and time commitments as common barriers, along with a lack of awareness about the needs of local fire departments and a sense of exclusivity with a role commonly passed down through generations.

“How do you tell an 18- or 19-year-old kid, ‘Hey, come and do all this stuff for us for free, and you get nothing in return?’ ” Mr. Chabalie said.

Some municipalities have taken steps to combat the issue by offering small financial incentives. 

In July 2024, officials approved a tax credit program for volunteer firefighters in Elizabeth Township, Elizabeth Borough and Forward. 

Advertise with us

By participating in at least 60 hours of service each year — through training, fundraising, vehicle or equipment repairs, administrative duties or responding to calls — they could qualify for a maximum property tax credit of $300.

The program came just six months after a similar initiative started in the East Allegheny School District, called the Volunteer Service Credit program. Firefighters volunteering in East McKeesport, North Versailles, Wall and Wilmerding could qualify for up to $3,000 in real estate tax relief through the program.

“I think this is something that should make a pulse to the entirety of Pennsylvania so other taxing bodies can come in and do the same thing and help their firefighters. This ain’t a North Versailles, East Allegheny thing. This is a Pennsylvania thing,” school director Merle Pusey told the Post-Gazette last year. 

Many departments also compete for grants through the Federal Emergency Management Agency for recruitment and retention efforts, including offering members small stipends.

“It's very difficult to get grants because it's so competitive, and everybody's trying to go for the same pot of money,” Mr. Chabalie said.

Advertise with us

Gov. Josh Shapiro also added a $30 million competitive grant for volunteer and paid fire departments in his 2025-26 budget to help pay for equipment, training and recruitment and retention efforts.

But grant money doesn’t get departments as far as it used to. 

Unlike full-time municipal fire departments — which typically have salaried staff, dedicated maintenance budgets and overnight station staffing — volunteer companies often operate on tight margins. 

“Because our buildings are aging and our apparatus is aging, we do our best to keep them maintained, but you can only do that for so long before you need to replace or renovate or anything like that,” Mr. Chabalie said.

“And the cost of everything these days is so much more expensive. In 2002, when we bought our one pumper, it was about $330,000. Now, if you want to get that same truck, or at least a very similar truck, you're looking at $1 million.”

Advertise with us
Firefighting gear hangs in the Elizabeth Township Fire Department, Station 140, in Elizabeth Township on Friday. Jim Chabalie, captain at the station, says it costs between $6,000-$7,000 to equip each firefighter. (Steve Mellon / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

‘We have to have each other’s backs’

In much of the country, fire protection looks different than it does in Pennsylvania. 

Many states rely more heavily on paid, career firefighters or a combination of paid staff and volunteers who cover daytime or weekend shifts. 

Pennsylvania, by contrast, has the third-largest percentage of registered volunteer departments, following Delaware and South Dakota, according to FEMA.

But several firefighters said residents often don’t realize that the people showing up at their doors in the middle of the night are neighbors doing it for free.

“A couple years ago, I went from laying in bed to being inside a burning house within seven minutes,” Chief Austin of the Logan Ferry Heights VFD said. “So to try to understand that dynamic, it is sometimes a little harder for people to wrap their head around.”

Advertise with us

The reliance on volunteers also means emergency response looks different from township to township. 

Some departments have more equipment to carry water to a scene while others have search-and-rescue capabilities, meaning neighboring departments will often request assistance from one another. 

The Office of the State Fire Commissioner is also seeing more regionalization efforts that include mergers, mutual aid and consolidations. In Elizabeth Township, the fire department’s station 140 is made up of three stations that include 25 to 30 active members, Mr. Chabalie said.

“Municipalities, who ultimately hold the responsibility for providing fire protection, are required to be more thoughtful and creative than ever with how they distribute their limited resources to meet the needs of their communities,” Mr. DeBrunner of the OSFC said. 

As a result, the resources that show up to burning structures can vary widely depending on the day, the time and who is able to leave their job or home to answer the call. 

“I think that people see that there's a fire station in my neighborhood, I'm safe, and they're always going to be there for us, but in reality, in this day and age, that may not always be the case,” Mr. Chabalie said. “We have to have each other's backs and be there for each other for the common good and common goal of keeping people safe.”