Tucked away in Harmar is Werner Camp, where narrow gravel paths lead into a quiet stretch of homes along the Allegheny River. 

From their porches, residents watch boats cruise by and the seasonal movement of birds overhead as they sip on their morning coffee. 

The view, the calm and the sense of privacy is what drew 64-year-old Ryan Bills and his wife, Holly, to the community 12 years ago. 

What the neighborhood didn’t have was fire hydrants — a problem he said he wouldn’t fully grasp until his next door neighbor’s home went up in flames one morning this past summer, damaging some of his own property in the process. 

Advertise with us

Away from home at the time, Mr. Bills watched through a Ring camera as residents, including his wife, frantically scurried outside and made space for firefighters to tackle a growing blaze that started just before 5 a.m. 

The absence of hydrants in the neighborhood forced crews to shut down the typically busy Freeport Road and active railroad tracks to access the nearest hydrant, located across the street next to a Target.

“We never considered anything like this happening,” Mr. Bills said last week. “But when the first one happens, then it comes to the forefront and becomes the main issue.”

With a patchwork of rules and responsibilities that vary per municipality, some communities in Western Pennsylvania are left with less fire protection than others. Fire hydrants can shave precious minutes off response times, potentially making a difference between partial damage and the total loss of a home. 

But jurisdiction over hydrants — from installation to maintenance and inspection — often falls into a gray area, leaving residents unsure of who’s ultimately responsible for keeping them safe. 

Advertise with us

For many residents in Harmar, the incident highlighted that exact question: Who’s responsible for installing fire hydrants at Werner Camp — the township, Oakmont Water Authority or the camp’s property owner, Evergreen Werner Hancock? 

Harmar supervisors and Evergreen Werner Hancock did not respond to several requests for comment for this story.

“You can't fight city hall, and you can't really fight Evergreen, either. So you just pay your bills and just keep living, that's all,” Mr. Bills said.

When hydrants aren’t available

Just a couple of weeks before the Aug. 2 fire at Werner Camp, Tyler Kelly, deputy fire chief of the Allegheny Valley Volunteer Fire Company, was in the neighborhood for a training activity in locating fire hydrants. 

During the exercise, a firefighter assigned him an address within the camp that he immediately recognized.

Advertise with us

“I stopped him and I said, ‘There's no hydrants down there. We know there’s never been a hydrant in Werner Camp,’” he recalled. 

Mr. Kelly moved on to the next address that day, but the interaction was fresh in his mind when his department got the call the morning of the fire at Werner Camp.

“We were aware from the minute that fire was dispatched that we weren't going to have an easily accessible hydrant,” he said.

A fire tore through this home in August on Werner Camp Road in Harmar. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

For other firefighters responding to that call — Mr. Kelly believes Allegheny Valley was the third out of several volunteer departments to arrive at the scene — the reality of the challenges set in once they got there.

Archived radio dispatches from that morning captured one firefighter asking whether there were hydrants in the neighborhood. After several seconds, it was determined that the closest one was around 500 feet away at Denny Estates, a neighboring private community.

Advertise with us

But a chained-up gate stood in the way, Mr. Kelly said.

Adding to the challenges, he said, one fire department that has a tanker — a vehicle able to transport large volumes of water — didn’t have a crew available to bring it. 

And as for getting water from the river, stairs to the riverbank were burned and unusable, meaning the department had no way of pumping the volume of water needed to put the fire out, Mr. Kelly explained.

So, fire crews had to get creative. 

They called local police to close off Freeport Road and Norfolk Southern Railway to shut down the railroad tracks. Crews were said to have worked for nearly three hours before turning the scene over to the Allegheny County Fire Marshal’s Office — which later determined it was an accidental fire “due to smoking.” 

Advertise with us

No one was injured in the blaze.

“I truly think for the situation that we were put in, to have that difficult water supply and to get those big trucks in and out of that neighborhood, I don't think the situation could have gone any better than it did,” Mr. Kelly said.

The property owner, Evergreen Werner Hancock, told Post-Gazette news partner KDKA-TV at the time that the company acquired the property in 2020 and was never notified by the township that hydrants were required. 

"After the fire [Aug. 2], we contacted Harmar Township, and they informed us that the township suggested the idea of installing fire hydrants to the prior owners, but they chose not to install them. We have reached out to the Oakmont Water Authority about installing hydrants,” the company added. 

James McCaskey, general manager of the Oakmont Water Authority, confirmed a call was received from “someone affiliated with Werner Camp,” but a meeting had yet to be scheduled. He could not confirm the date of the call.

Advertise with us

“In general, the placement of the fire hydrants is determined by local municipalities and the local fire departments, and the installation is done at their expense,” Mr. McCaskey told the Post-Gazette. “If the property is privately owned, then all expenses are paid by the owner. Once the hydrants are installed, the authority then maintains them.”

When hydrants don’t work

In other parts of the region, the problem isn’t necessarily a lack of fire hydrants — it’s whether the hydrants actually work.

Even in Pittsburgh, the city’s fire chief, Darryl Jones, said that while it’s rare, his firefighters have encountered hydrants that are dry or in other ways compromised during a fire response.

“The main problem that it causes is a delay in getting water on the fire. We have water in our trucks, but it doesn't last but a couple minutes. 

“So if they hit a hydrant that's not functioning, that delays them and they have to find a new water supply,” he said. 

Advertise with us

And depending on what’s burning, that fire can “grow exponentially for each minute of delay,” he added.

Not even two months before the Werner Camp fire, a home in the Town and Country Estates mobile home park in Canton Township, Washington County, went up in flames. When emergency personnel arrived, they found none of the neighborhood’s fire hydrants to be working.

South Strabane Township Fire and Emergency Services Chief Jordan Cramer told the Post-Gazette at the time that firefighters dispatched to that park had encountered hydrants without adequate water during at least one other incident in the past three years.

“Everyone that lives in that community is extremely concerned about the lack of fire hydrants, about the fact that they do not work there,” he said. “The residents of that community are voicing their opinion as loud as they possibly can for action to be taken.”

Residents in East Huntingdon, Westmoreland County, also expressed frustration over hydrants that weren’t working during a fire that tore through a doublewide home on Holiday Court Road in October 2024.

Advertise with us

“I don't know what happened there because that's a private area. We don’t [maintain] roads or anything down where that happened,” said Jeff Keefer, an East Huntingdon Township supervisor.

Mr. Keefer, who also is a firefighter for East Huntingdon’s volunteer fire company, said he was unsure whether the responsibility for maintaining the hydrants in that neighborhood fell on the property owners or the water provider, the Municipal Authority of Westmoreland County.

And while he doesn’t know the authority’s maintenance schedule, he said he doesn’t believe they “test them enough to know on a daily basis whether a hydrant is not going to perform.” 

According to an authority newsletter, it maintains more than 8,400 hydrants – which are all mapped out by GPS coordinates and checked every two years. Results of flow tests are also relayed to the 911 center.

But unless there’s severe damage to a hydrant or a water break occurs, Mr. Keefer said the local fire department isn’t always aware of that status.

Advertise with us

“If there’s an incident [the water authority doesn’t] know about, then you get there and you get a surprise.”

The Municipal Authority of Westmoreland County could not be reached for immediate comment.

No one size fits all

Private property owners are held to a different standard of maintaining their hydrants than a municipality itself, leading to some of the confusion.

On the private side, the National Fire Protection Association requires hydrants to be tested annually, typically by opening the hydrant and conducting a flow test. 

But on the public side, a standard set by the American Water Works Association states that it is up to the municipality to develop a schedule for testing and maintaining the hydrants within their system, as well as the specific criteria for doing so.

Advertise with us

“There is language in that AWWA standard that says if you're going to have a water supply system, it should meet this criteria. Now, whether or not the individual municipality has adopted that as their criteria really is up to the individual municipality,” said Robin Zevotek, principal fire protection engineer at the NFPA. 

This home, photographed on Tuesday, Nov. 25, 2025, had a fire break out in August at Werner Camp in Harmar Twp. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In Allegheny County, where Pennsylvania American Water is responsible for 8,000 fire hydrants, inspections take place once per year. 

That includes testing the flow rate and residual pressure in each hydrant, as well as conducting exercises to make sure caps can be easily removed in an emergency, according to Pennsylvania American spokeswoman Lauren Camarda.

If hydrant defects are reported or discovered during an inspection, local fire departments are notified and the hydrant is typically repaired or replaced within 72 hours, Ms. Camarda added. 

Out of all the hydrants the authority maintains in Allegheny County, she estimated that not more than five may be out of service at any given time.

Advertise with us

Pittsburgh Water, which maintains about 7,500 hydrants, inspects a third of them annually as part of a three-year inspection program. 

Inspection steps include opening and flushing the hydrant, taking a pressure reading, then removing and lubricating the nozzles, company spokeswoman Rebecca Zito said. 

Pittsburgh Water also shares fire hydrant GIS mapping with the city’s Bureau of Fire and its Public Safety Department.

‘It woke everybody up’

As residents in the region brace for a cold winter, officials advise those who have questions about their fire hydrants to contact their local water authority. 

Pennsylvania American’s hydrants can be identified by their yellow color and they typically have a ring or collar that lists the company’s name. 

Advertise with us

Rings are also placed around hydrants maintained by Pittsburgh Water; they include contact information as well.

Should another fire occur in Werner Camp, Mr. Kelly, the deputy fire chief, said his members will use the same strategy they did in August. 

But the fire department has also advised residents to reach out to the township, the water authority and the landowner about putting in hydrants.

“There could be an issue, like that fire, that there's no fire hydrants close by, but I think we did the best with what we had to work with,” he said. 

With that warning in mind, residents have formed a group and are seeking a solution that makes them all feel safe. 

“[The owners] should have a responsibility for the safety of their tenants, and at this point, I don't feel that we are as safe as we could be,” said Dennis Tovey, 73. “And it just slapped us right in the face with that fire. It woke everybody up.”