At least three churches line the stretch of Frankstown Road between Evaline Street and Duff Road in Penn Hills.
The roadway is the picture of suburbia — single-family homes along quiet side streets to the north and south, and automobile-related shops, small businesses and retail chains along its length.
Just off of Duff, McDonald’s golden arches match a bright yellow sign outside a furniture repair shop on Evaline.
Early last week, the busy roadway was the site of a pair of unrelated fatal shootings, rattling nearby neighbors and businesses and causing some property damage. But just a few days later, residents continued their normal shopping routines at the nearby Giant Eagle and Big Lots.
Danielle Jackson Thorn was watching a movie Monday evening in her living room on Duff Road.
Suddenly, she heard a noise that didn’t come from her TV.
A bullet had hit her apartment window, leaving a large crack. Had it struck a different spot, things could have unfolded much differently.
“I could’ve been hit,” she said. “It just makes you think how fragile things are.”
A man was killed in that shooting, near the intersection of Frankstown and Duff.
A six-minute drive down Frankstown, two women were shot just a day earlier. One of the women died the next day.
Authorities are still investigating both shootings.
Ongoing violence
Of the 130 municipalities in Allegheny County, Penn Hills has seen the third highest number of homicides since 2007, according to the Allegheny County Department of Human Services. There were 93 homicides reported by the Allegheny County Medical Examiner’s Office in Penn Hills from 2007 through May 2025, not including the two homicides this month.
Many residents with whom the Post-Gazette spoke in the days after the shootings said their lives had been affected by gun violence before, so they were not necessarily surprised about the recent incidents.
Rebecca Clark, 43, moved to Penn Hills in December. On the night she arrived, as she was unpacking her things from a U-Haul truck, she heard gunshots down her street.
“I hope they get it together, because I don't plan on moving,” said Ms. Clark, who revealed that a cousin was killed by gunfire two years ago. “Everybody’s got to learn to come together.”
The Rev. John Welch, a pastor who for 50 years has lived in Pittsburgh’s East Hills, which borders Penn Hills, said addressing gun violence requires a “broader approach" and intervention for children at a young age.
“We've got to find some earlier upstream disruptors,” he said. “This violence just creates violence, because the trauma doesn't slip through these kids ... that's all that they know how to respond to situations.”
The role of police officers, particularly in large municipalities such as Penn Hills, often can come under scrutiny after acts of violence. In an effort to address gun violence, more officers have been hired and officials are discussing implementation of “other ideas” to increase safety, Mayor Pauline Calabrese has said.
The Penn Hills Police Department covers roughly 20 square miles with up to 10 officers per shift, said police Chief Ronald Como. Penn Hills, the second-largest municipality in Allegheny County, has about 60 full-time police officers, according to its website.
Chief Como acknowledged that a single police department cannot fully prevent violent crimes, particularly those involving firearms.
“In law enforcement, there are limits to our ability to deter all crimes,” he said.
How officers are perceived in a community can also play a role, said Annamarie Sauers, 64, of Penn Hills.
Many kids are under the assumption that police are only present when there are “bad guys,” Ms. Sauers said, and police incorporating themselves into the community can help address that perception.
“Then we could get to know our officers like we know our mailman,” Ms. Sauers said.
Community comes together
Chandler Scull, president and director of Starlight Strays Sanctuary, a cat rescue organization, has lived in Penn Hills for nearly five years.
Her storefront is along Frankstown near where Ms. Thorn lives — and where bullets were fired Monday evening.
At Starlight Strays, cats typically roam the adoption center, lying on couches and climbing cat trees.
As gunshots rang out Monday, police told Ms. Scull, cats lined the windows, watching as a man collapsed outside and as paramedics and police flooded the area.
There were “people everywhere” outside Starlight Strays in the aftermath of the shooting, Ms. Scull said. Several people stopped by the business in the days after the shooting to see how she and other business owners and residents were coping.
Ms. Scull was not inside the cat rescue when the shooting occurred. When she heard about it, she described herself as moving around in a “haze.”
The rescue’s maintenance manager pulled her out of it.
“He gave me a big hug and said, ‘Are you OK?” Ms. Scull recalled.
Ms. Scull immediately started texting everyone she could who lived or worked nearby.
“It just seemed like everyone rallied, stood outside, and talked and checked in on each other,” she said. “As hard as this was, it was really reassuring to feel that.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.