Attorneys representing East Palestine and its surrounding communities in the historic settlement against Norfolk Southern say residents could receive much more money than expected.

Earlier this year, Norfolk Southern agreed to pay $600 million for damages from the 2023 train derailment that spewed hazardous cargo and left residents with fears for their health and the environment. This marks the largest settlement in U.S. history involving a train derailment, covering anyone who lived or worked within a 20-mile radius from the accident.

During a virtual town hall on Thursday evening, the legal teams who reached the agreement with the railroad explained key deadlines coming soon for residents who wish to take part and announced that some compensation estimates have doubled. 

Those who are eligible for the personal injury component, or residents who live within 10 miles from the derailment, are now expected to receive roughly $25,000, attorneys said. The legal team initially estimated that individuals who elected to participate in the personal injury payment would receive about $10,000. 

Advertise with us

Adam Gomez, a partner with Grant & Eisenhofer, said they didn’t want to overpromise and gave “very conservative” numbers. In exchange for this money, people must waive their rights to sue Norfolk Southern for any personal injuries that may arise in the future. 

“We used historical data and other resources to gauge what those payments could be like, always explaining that they could change upwards as we received more claims information,” Mr. Gomez said. “We're now at the point.”

The settlement money is intended to help residents recover from the accident, including addressing healthcare needs and medical monitoring, property restoration, business losses and other potential impacts. What households see in their final paychecks depends on how many claims are filed by the August 22 deadline. The judge overseeing the case must also approve it, with a hearing scheduled in September. If all goes to plan, the settlement checks will be sent out by the end of the year. 

During the Thursday meeting, attorneys said that people could see second or even third payments from the settlement fund, depending on the number of claims that come through. There is also opportunity to receive more money for “extraordinary circumstances,” where, for example, someone may suffer from particular chemical sensitivities or a predisposition to respiratory problems that made the chemical impacts that much worse.

“Those extraordinary circumstances can be a very adverse reaction to the chemical exposure,” Mr. Gomez said. “They can be an illness or symptoms that are different from those that have been experienced by most.”

Advertise with us

Residents have shared concerns with the Post-Gazette about the settlement terms and whether it goes far enough to help residents recoup. By the time the opt-out and objection deadline arrived on July 1, fewer than 1% of the estimated 190,000 eligible households decided to opt out.

With the new estimates in place, Mr. Gomez laid out what the settlement outcome could look like for a “fully participating” family of five, meaning the household opted into all of the settlement benefits. That family, according to Mr. Gomez, could expect to get $70,000 from the larger direct payment and then about $125,000 in personal injury payments, or $25,000 per person. In total, based on the new approximations, the family could see about $195,000. 

Michelle Kranz, a partner with Zoll & Kranz, and president of the Ohio State Bar Association, encouraged residents to act now if they haven’t already and ensure they meet the Aug. 22 deadline to file their claims. 

“There are no extensions, there are no opportunities to file late,” she said. “That is a date set in stone, and it's certainly done for the protection of those who file claims and allow some certainty in the claims process.”

Chad Edwards, who became East Palestine’s village manager last November, also made an appearance at the virtual gathering to express his support for residents. He acknowledged that he can’t understand the derailment’s effects in the same way because he didn’t experience the disaster himself. “But I am here for you,” he told attendees.

“I really don't know what the best option would be in any particular situation,” he added. “The purpose of this is just to try to give you the information to help you make that decision.”