Leaders in East Palestine, Ohio are calling on the federal government to do more to protect the long-term health and safety of its reeling residents.
In May, the U.S. Department of Justice and Environmental Protection Agency announced a $310 million agreement with Norfolk Southern to hold the railroad operator accountable for the Feb. 3, 2023, train derailment.
If approved by a federal court in Ohio, the settlement would require Norfolk Southern to fund a community health program to address medical needs stemming from the disaster. It also requires the company to fund clean-up efforts, restore the region’s waterways, monitor the drinking water system and pay a $15 million penalty.
But local officials think the deal falls short. A letter signed by Village Manager Chad Edwards scrutinizes the lack of provisions for medical treatment, inadequate funding for health services and other gaps. The response was submitted to the DOJ as a part of a 30-day public comment period, which ended earlier this month.
"Our residents deserve a settlement that truly addresses the full scope of the impact from the derailment,” Mr. Edwards said in a news release. “We are hopeful that the DOJ will consider our comments and work with us to ensure a just resolution."
East Palestine Fire Chief Keith Drabick has been at the table during recent conversations between village leadership and officials at the DOJ and EPA. He said the agencies have been open to their concerns, but the situation remains “fluid.” The DOJ is still reviewing the public feedback as it considers making changes to the settlement terms.
Read More
“It's a work in progress,” Mr. Drabick said. “Our primary concern is just ensuring the long-term health and safety of our residents in East Palestine and the first responders.”
The village told the DOJ it can’t stand behind a settlement that does not provide for medical treatment of any kind. As the agreement stands, residents will have to rely on their insurance, workers compensation or pay-out-of-pocket to treat health problems that may arise.
Officials argue that these costs “fall squarely” on Norfolk Southern.
“Residents shouldn't have to bear the consequences of the derailment and the measures outlined in that decree have to be equitable,” Mr. Drabick said. “Part of that is fair and accessible health services.”
The settlement requires Norfolk Southern to pay $19.5 for medical monitoring and $5.5 million for mental health services as part of a Community Health Program. Residents would receive free medical exams, like blood panels and x-rays, annually for almost two decades.
But the village is wary that the allotted funds will not stretch far enough to cover all those services over time.
Based on data obtained from local health providers, the village estimates that the costs would exceed $5 million a year if every person were to utilize the health care services. That means the pot of money would only cover a fraction of the 15-year time period it’s supposed to cover. Officials urge the DOJ to significantly increase that funding.
Like the letter, Mr. Drabick points out, too, that the settlement doesn’t include critical tests, such as combined blood count (CBC) and urinalysis, that have been standard since the derailment. From the expertise of environmental and health experts tapped by the village, it’s clear that this kind of testing would be “crucial” for early detection of conditions related to toxin exposure, Mr. Drabick said.
Outside of health concerns, local officials argue that the settlement doesn’t go far enough to address water safety. While Norfolk Southern will pay $15 million to monitor local wells and groundwater for the next 10 years, it’s unclear what responsibility the company will have if contamination is found. For now, it’s all under “vague” terms where the company must only conduct an “environmental benefit analysis and coordinate with the EPA, according to the letter.
East Palestine Wastewater Superintendent Scott Wolf would like to see the DOJ clearly outline accountability measures for Norfolk Southern, especially if toxins are found in the public water system. So far, continued monthly sampling of the village’s wells has indicated no contamination, Mr. Scott said, and carbon filters were installed as a precautionary measure this past June.
“The community's water is our most precious asset,” Mr. Wolf said. “We need to have the assurances that the proper mechanisms are all in place for who's to cover contamination if something were to come up.”
The DOJ and EPA’s agreement is separate from the $600 million class action suit that will resolve property and personal injury claims from residents - the largest payout for a train derailment in the country.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.