HARRISBURG — The total of 16 deficiencies found by state reviewers at Allegheny County’s Older Adults Protective Services office was tied for the highest number among such programs in Pennsylvania since early 2023, but a county spokesperson says things are improving.
Protective services programs look into reports of abuse, neglect, abandonment and exploitation of senior citizens. The programs typically are run by county agency on aging organizations.
The Allegheny program is one of six currently out of compliance with state regulations, according to a review of recent Pennsylvania Department of Aging notification letters shared with the Post-Gazette by the department. Of the six, the Allegheny and Philadelphia programs had the most deficiencies, with 16 each.
“The 16 deficiencies identified by the PDA were the result of incomplete case documentation in the [Social Assistance Management] system and a few procedural items,” Allegheny County spokesperson Mark Bertolet said in an email.
After an August, 2023, letter from the state notified it of the deficiencies and that it was out of compliance with state regulations, he said, the office took “prompt and thorough action.” He said that included creating a corrective action plan, carrying out training, and many other steps that have led to a big drop in the number of open cases.
State Aging Department spokesperson Karen Gray said it sent 48 letters to county-level agencies with protective services programs between Jan. 1, 2023, and the end of February, 2024. She said they were exempt from disclosure under the state Right-to-Know Law, but were shared with the Post-Gazette as a courtesy.
Read More
Six of the 48 letters said the program in question was out of compliance with the law, regulations, and department policy, and identified deficiencies. Another letter – involving the program in Lackawanna County and dated Jan. 12, 2023 – informed the local agency that “six areas of non-compliance were identified” during the review period, but at the same time identified no deficiencies and gave the agency an “overall compliance monitoring score” of 89%. A subsequent letter dated Jan. 17, 2024, said “your agency has been designated as in compliance.”
A department spokesperson said the language in the Jan. 12, 2023, letter was not clear and it was issued prior to new leadership taking over the department.
Ms. Gray said no other programs have been notified of non-compliance since the end of February.
Concern about victimization of seniors has increased. The Associated Press reported in December that the number of deaths of older Pennsylvanians following an abuse or neglect complaint went from 120 in 2017 to almost 1,400 in 2022.
The state’s 52 agencies on aging – some cover multiple counties – help seniors with a broad array of services, including fielding complaints about abuse. The list of agencies that are not in compliance with state regulations is not readily available to the public.
The Allegheny operation’s non-compliance came to public attention in February when state Rep. Louis Schmitt, R-Blair, questioned Aging Secretary Jason Kavulich during a legislative hearing.
On Tuesday, Mr. Schmitt said he intends to introduce a bill that would require regular publication of a list of “triple-A’s that are non-compliant.” He also said he will push for those agencies’ corrective action plans to be made public.
“We have got to do better than this,” Mr. Schmitt said. “We have got to shine a light on this.”
Mr. Gray said the department is working on a plan to make its data on monitoring of agencies more publicly available.
Besides Allegheny and Philadelphia, the protective services programs currently in non-compliance are in Westmoreland, Mercer, Delaware, and Lehigh counties.
Westmoreland Agency on Aging Administrator Carrie Nelson said the county “continuously strives for compliance” and has retrained staff and added new personnel. The administrator of the Mercer agency, Sandra Swogger, said trouble filling open positions was one cause of the issues in the state findings.
“We had some staffing challenges, and that created some problems,” she said. “We will get somebody trained, and they move on.”
The Mercer agency, she said, takes state requirements seriously. “We are resolving all of the issues we have had in the past,” Ms. Swogger said.
In Allegheny County, the Office of Older Adult Protective Services operates within the agency on aging, which itself is part of the Department of Human Services. The state letter to Agency on Aging Administrator Shannah Tharp-Gilliam on non-compliance and the 16 deficiencies was dated Aug. 16.
Mr. Bertolet said the agency submitted a corrective action plan to the state on Aug. 31 and it was approved on Sept. 13.
“We have made very significant strides in increasing the quality of investigations in OAPS in Allegheny County,” he said. However, he said, only the state can reclassify the program as being back in compliance.
A statewide increase in the number of abuse reports in recent years has been reflected in Allegheny County, he said, straining the investigative capacity of the local office.
For example, he said, in April, 2022, the office received 301 cases. At the time, he said, the office had a capacity to process 168 cases a month – 21 investigators handling 8 cases each per month.
“Which means that at that time, the system had 133 cases more than it could handle,” Mr. Bertolet said.
The Allegheny protective services unit maintains an online data dashboard. Mr. Bertolet said the program takes potential deficiencies seriously and its work includes face-to-face, on-site visits.
A series of improvements to staffing and processes, he said, have led to a 52% reduction in the number of open cases at the office: from 1,559 active cases in February, 2023, to 789 active cases a year later. Those improvements include:
- Dedicating money to the office’s provider agencies “to increase investigator and supervisor salaries to add in retention and recruitment.”
- Taking on a new, contracted protective services provider “to provide staff to support and augment investigative activities to promote efficiency and effectiveness in the investigative process.”
- The office established a protective services-specific training department and training curriculum for Allegheny County. Mr. Bertolet said it was “believed to be the only known such county AAA dedicated training program” in the state.
- Putting in place a new model that allows multiple investigators to work a case simultaneously.
Ms. Gray said Mr. Kavulich has led “a department-wide and Aging network-wide effort to maximize our network’s ability to fully act on behalf of the older Pennsylvanians within our authority.”
Ford Turner: fturner@post-gazette.com





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.