Parties in a lengthy court fight over Scaife family trust funds should not be allowed to privately litigate matters without notifying the newspapers that have intervened in the case, an attorney for the Pittsburgh Post-Gazette and Philadelphia Inquirer argued in court Tuesday.
For several months, parties in the case related to a nine-figure trust fund emptied by the late Richard Mellon Scaife have been filing sealed motions related to heiress Jennie Scaife's failure to submit to a deposition. The attorneys say that they have filed the motions under seal because they include medical and psychological information. Attorney Frederick Frank, representing the two newspapers, cited agreements reached since 2014 in which parties in the case must justify any bids to seal records from public scrutiny.
Newspapers have "a unique role as the representative of the public, so that the public can understand, in the bright light of day, how judicial matters are being handled," Mr. Frank told Allegheny County Common Pleas Judge Kathleen Durkin. They can't fulfill that role if parties file pleadings under seal without even informing the newspapers' legal representative, he argued.
Attorney Peter St. Tienne Wolff, representing Ms. Scaife, countered that new public access rules handed down by the state Supreme Court trump any agreements made in the case. Under those rules, medical and psychological records can't be filed in a publicly accessible manner, so they have to be sealed, he said.
Mr. Frank presented to Judge Durkin a series of proposed orders meant to ensure that all efforts to seal documents are disclosed to the newspapers, which can then object.
Ms. Scaife, 55, of Florida, and her brother David Scaife, 52, of Shadyside, allege that their father spent down a trust they would otherwise have inherited as he propped up his Trib Total Media properties, while sparing other resources which he left to charity or to his newspaper holdings.
Read More
They claim that trustees H. Yale Gutnick, (the former chairman of Trib Total Media), PNC Bank and James Walton should not have allowed their father to drain some $400 million, over 20 years, from the fund created in 1935 from which they would have inherited any balance. The fund was empty upon Mr. Scaife's death in 2014.
The case, launched in November 2014, appears to have slowed because Ms. Scaife hasn't been deposed. Mr. Gutnick's attorneys have been demanding the opportunity to depose her since late 2015. Seven months ago, Judge Durkin ordered that she make herself available for a deposition in Florida, for a few hours per day.
"When I went to schedule the deposition in accordance with the order, Jennie Scaife refused to schedule her deposition," said attorney James Schadel, representing Mr. Gutnick. "The defense that was raised was all about her medical condition. ... I can't say more about what her reasons are for her not coming to her deposition. That's the confidential stuff" in the pleadings.
A portion of the court argument was closed to the press. Afterward, attorney William Pietragallo, representing Ms. Scaife, reiterated that his client's reasons for postponing her deposition are private.
"I very much want her to be deposed when appropriate," Mr. Pietragallo said. He noted that another witness in the case, who he would not name, has also had his or her deposition postponed for health reasons.
When might Ms. Scaife answer questions? "Can't answer that," said Mr. Pietragallo. "People have health reasons that they can't proceed, and it happens." He said her health problems should not affect the outcome of the case.
Mr. Gutnick's attorneys declined to comment.
Rich Lord: rlord@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1542




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.