A juror in Bill Cosby’s sex assault trial said Thursday that he did not believe the testimony of accuser Andrea Constand because she willingly went alone to the entertainer’s home and brought him gifts on more than one occasion.

“She was well-coached,” he said of Ms. Constand’s two days on the witness stand. “Let’s face it: She went up to his house with a bare midriff and incense and bath salts. What the heck?”

The juror, who spoke at his home in Pittsburgh on the condition of anonymity, declined to say whether he wanted to convict or acquit Mr. Cosby. But he said the seven men and five women on the panel were nearly evenly split after 52 hours of deliberations, a deadlock that prompted Montgomery County Common Pleas Judge Steven T. O’Neill to declare a mistrial Saturday. And he said Mr. Cosby had already “paid dearly” for the allegations and shouldn’t be retried.

The juror was the second to offer a window into the deliberation room of the case, and his account appeared to contradict the first. That juror told ABC News on Monday that 10 of the 12 panel members were prepared to find Mr. Cosby guilty on two of the three counts against him.

Advertise with us

The juror who discussed the case Thursday said at one point deep into deliberations, there had been a 10-2 vote to convict Mr. Cosby of drugging and sexually assaulting Ms. Constand, but three panel members later changed their votes and wanted to acquit him.

Votes were split “up the middle: young and old, black and white, men and women,” he said.

He said he thought the jury failed to reach a unanimous verdict because the language describing the charges — three counts of aggravated indecent assault stemming from an incident in 2004 — was confusing and “too legal.”

Jurors struggled over words such as “reckless” and “severely impaired” while debating whether Mr. Cosby drugged and molested Ms. Constand, he said. Some of their requests to review testimony during deliberations, he said, were specifically based on wanting to find those words in the evidence.

“We were trying to match the testimony up with the charges,” he said. “Everybody’s interpretation of those words was something different.”

Advertise with us

He spoke a day after Judge O’Neill, acting on a petition from news outlets, released the names of the 12 jurors and six alternates who were chosen in Allegheny County and sequestered for the trial near Norristown. Most have since refused to comment on the case or their deliberations, following a directive from the judge.

Though the juror who spoke Thursday didn’t reveal his vote, he did make clear his skepticism about Ms. Constand, the 44-year-old accuser from Toronto who said she viewed Mr. Cosby only as a friend and mentor and never sought a romantic relationship. Specifically, the juror said, she should have gone to Mr. Cosby’s home only if she was “dressed properly and left the incense in the store,” referring to a gift that she brought him when the two formed a friendship before the alleged assault.

In a deposition read to jurors, Mr. Cosby detailed a sexual liaison he had with Ms. Constand when she showed up at his home with her midriff exposed, some time before the night of the alleged assault. Mr. Constand denies that encounter ever occurred.​

Still, the juror’s impression seemed to echo the trial defense Mr. Cosby’s lawyers sought to present: that Constand, then a 31-year-old Temple University employee, was in or seeking a romantic relationship with the then-66-year-old entertainer and university trustee.

He said he found Mr. Cosby’s own words in 2005, to police and in the deposition for a lawsuit filed by Ms. Constand, to be convincing. In that deposition and since, Mr. Cosby maintained any sexual contact was consensual.

Advertise with us

“He was extremely honest, he admitted to things,” the juror said.

He also saw Ms. Constand’s mother as the driving force behind her decision to report the alleged assault to police a year after it occurred. “It was her mother who forced all this,” said the panel member.

And he said the jury didn’t let the allegations of the more than 60 women who have come forward to accuse Mr. Cosby of sexual misconduct influence its decision. He said he believes many of those women have fabricated their claims.

“This is ridiculous, unbelievable,” he said. “I think more than half jumped on the bandwagon.”

Jurors did not yell or argue during deliberations, he said, but the room was tense, once draped in prolonged silence.

Advertise with us

“There may have been one 10-minute break of total silence and then the question came up: Did the courthouse have a chapel?” he said.

There was no chapel, and deliberations continued. But in the end, he said, “the jury was stalled on everything.”

Mr. Cosby, 79, “has paid dearly” already for the allegations against him, the juror said, because his career has been destroyed. He said he doesn’t think District Attorney Kevin R. Steele should pursue a retrial, as he has said he will do.

“They should’ve left if closed … there wasn’t enough evidence to move the case forward,” he said, echoing Mr. Cosby’s lawyer’s arguments about the 2005 decision by then-District Attorney Bruce L. Castor Jr. to close the case without charging Mr. Cosby.

Now, he said, there was nothing to consider beyond decade-old evidence. “No stained garment, no smoking gun, nothing,” the juror said.