The Diocese of Pittsburgh last year reached a “five-figure” settlement with a man who claimed he was sexually abused as a youth by a priest whom then-Bishop Anthony Bevilacqua brought into the diocese despite knowing of his history and risk of sexual predatory behavior.

The out-of-court settlement, reached in October, was announced this week by Boston lawyer Mitchell Garabedian, who said his client was repeatedly molested by the Rev. John P. Connor, a New Jersey priest who worked in the North Hills in the 1980s.

Allegations of Father Connor’s serial attacks on youths before and after his Pittsburgh tenure were documented in a 2005 grand jury report on the Archdiocese of Philadelphia, where the late Cardinal Bevilacqua later brought Father Connor.

But this settlement provides the first allegation that Father Connor also used his time in the Diocese of Pittsburgh to groom and sexually assault at least one youth.

Advertise with us

Mr. Garabedian said he was releasing news of the settlement, alongside several others recently reached with the Archdiocese of Boston, to prod Catholic officials into becoming more transparent about priests and others who used their authority in the church to sexually abuse children.

“In so listing the perpetrators, transparency exists, which helps victims/​survivors heal and gain a degree of closure,” said Mr. Garabedian, whose long role of representing clergy-abuse survivors was prominently featured in the recent movie ”Spotlight,” about the scandal in Boston. “Once again the question remains: Where were the supervisors, and why weren’t they protecting children?”

The abuse occurred while Father Connor worked at St. Alphonsus Church in suburban Pine, he said.

The abuse occurred over two years when his client was between 12 and 14, according to Mr. Garabedian. It occurred in Father Connor’s car, in a Pittsburgh movie theater and on a basketball court in Bradford Woods, he said.

The Rev. Ronald Lengwin, a spokesman for the diocese, confirmed the settlement. He said Mr. Garabedian’s client originally contacted the diocese anonymously in 2008 before the attorney contacted the diocese on his behalf in December 2014.

Advertise with us

Mike Manko, spokesman for Allegheny County District Attorney Stephen A. Zappala Jr., confirmed that the diocese turned over the information about Father Connor in January 2015 but that the case could not be prosecuted under the statute of limitations.

As the Post-Gazette reported in 2005 after the release of the Philadelphia grand jury report, Father Connor was a priest of the Diocese of Camden, N.J., whom then-Bishop Bevilacqua agreed to bring here in 1985. Father Connor had been arrested in New Jersey in 1984 on a charge of molesting a 14-year-old boy during a beach trip.

A pretrial agreement with New Jersey prosecutors enabled Father Connor to avoid a conviction if he stayed out of trouble for a year, according to the grand jury report.

After time at a church-affiliated treatment facility in Canada where sexually abusive priests were often sent, Camden’s then-Bishop George Guilfoyle asked Bishop Bevilacqua to accept him because Father Connor’s return to Camden would create scandal, the report said.

The Canada center, Southdown Institute in Ontario, had warned that Father Connor not work with adolescents, it said.

Advertise with us

The Rev. Nicholas Dattilo, then a clergy personnel aide in the Diocese of Pittsburgh, wrote in a 1985 memo he was aware of the history of “bishops helping bishops” with sexually abusive priests and warned that “we could be accepting a difficulty with which we have no post-therapeutic experience” if Father Connor posed a “serious risk.”

Bishop Bevilacqua handwrote on the memo, “I cannot guarantee that there is no serious risk,” yet assigned him anyway, with Father Dattilo’s reluctant acquiescence, according to the grand jury report.

First, Bishop Bevilacqua assigned Father Connor as chaplain at Sewickley Valley Hospital in October 1985. The priest lived at St. James Church in Sewickley during that time, according to the Pittsburgh diocese.

From October 1986 to July 1988, Bishop Bevilacqua assigned Father Connor to work as parochial vicar at St. Alphonsus.

Bishop Bevilacqua left to take over the Archdiocese of Philadelphia in 1988.

Advertise with us

Later that year, new Bishop Donald Wuerl arrived and began taking a harder line against sexually abusive priests. Father Dattilo revoked Father Connor’s St. Alphonsus assignment and returned him to Camden’s jurisdiction. Then-Archbishop Bevilacqua brought Father Connor to work in the Philadelphia archdiocese, where the grand jury report said he maintained a questionable relationship with an adolescent male.

Father Connor was removed from ministry in 2002 and has been assigned “to a life of prayer and penance in a diocesan retirement facility,” according to spokesman Michael Walsh of the Diocese of Camden.

Father Dattilo went on to become bishop of Harrisburg and died in 2004.

Asked why the Diocese of Pittsburgh did not announce the settlement itself, Father Lengwin noted that Father Connor’s case had been reported as early as 2005 and the diocese provided its personnel documents to the Philadelphia grand jury.

“It had been out there so much to the public, we felt there wasn’t a need to do that,” he said, adding that there are posters and bulletin notices in every parish, plus other public notices in church settings, urging anyone who has been abused to come forward.

Advertise with us

News of the settlement caps a month that began with a Pennsylvania grand jury report outlining decades of abuse in the nearby Diocese of Altoona-Johnstown, then the arrests of three priests in a Hollidaysburg-based Franciscan province for allegedly covering up abuse by a late friar.

Peter Smith: petersmith@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1416; Twitter @PG_PeterSmith.