A Cambria County Common Pleas judge has resigned from the board of trustees of Bishop McCort Catholic High School in Johnstown the week after a grand jury report said he told an investigator he met with then-Bishop James Hogan over sexual abuse allegations against a priest who was transferred rather than being reported or investigated.
A statement from Patrick T. Kiniry said his name was “mentioned” in the recent 147-page grand jury report about a half-century of sexual misconduct in the Altoona-Johnstown Diocese. The judge confirmed his resignation.
“Since the release of the grand jury’s findings, Judge Kiniry, like everyone else, has been reading and digesting the contents of that report,” said Tripp Crilly, Judge Kiniry’s law clerk, reading a prepared statement. “As has been reported, Judge Kiniry has been mentioned in the report in connection with his service in 1985 as an assistant district attorney of Cambria County under then-District Attorney Gerard Long.
“As a person and a concerned member of this community, Judge Kiniry would like to respond and comment on some of the content of the report and media accounts thereof, but as a judge he simply cannot,” it stated.
Mark E. Pasquerilla of Pasquerilla Enterprises, who serves as board chairman, issued a statement that the Bishop McCort Catholic High School board of trustees has “accepted the resignation of Patrick Kiniry, effective immediately.”
Last week a grand jury report identified three groups of villains in the case: priests who abused hundreds of children, diocesan officials who protected the priests and civil authorities who looked the other way at times when they knew something was wrong.
There were various explanations of why police didn’t take action against specific priests, including the Rev. Leonard Inman and another priest identified as Joseph Gaborek. The report also detailed a 1985 meeting involving then-Bishop Hogan about his concern that allegations against the Msgr. Francis McCaa (now deceased) would go public.
Judge Kiniry, an assistant district attorney at the time and one of those who met with the bishop, said the decision about charging the priest would have been made by then-DA Long, who later became a Cambria County judge. An effort to reach Judge Long through Cambria County Court officials was unsuccessful. He retired from the bench in 2010.
The report states that Judge Kiniry told a special agent that he met with the bishop at the request of the district attorney.
“[Judge] Kiniry recalled that the allegations were that a priest was ‘messing around’ with children and that [Bishop] Hogan had concerns about ‘what to do with the priest.’” An agreement was made that Bishop Hogan would transfer the priest to another location, the report states.
“[Judge] Kiniry indicated the decision to not pursue charges would have been District Attorney Long’s decision.”
Asked if such a meeting with the bishop was unusual, “[Judge] Kiniry replied, ‘You have to understand, this is an extremely Catholic county,’” while adding he’d been an altar boy and attended a Catholic school.
Also asked about the decision to transfer the priest to another location, the report says that “[Judge] Kiniry stated, ‘Back then the diocese moved the problem. That’s just how it was, ’” further noting that it would be treated differently today and be “investigated and the priest would possibly be arrested.”
David Templeton: dtempleton@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1578.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.