Allegheny County Controller Chelsa Wagner’s suggestion that Port Authority use an unexpected $2.1 million in car rental tax funds to restore specific bus routes that it eliminated isn’t that simple, say other county and transit officials.
Ms. Wagner announced Thursday that Hertz Corp. owes the county an additional $1.44 million in back car rental taxes, penalties and interest that it failed to pay from January 2008 through April 2010. That’s on top of $743,107 the company paid in January to cover May 2010 through June 2011.
Hertz acknowledged in January that it inadvertently paid half of the $2-a-day tax to the state instead of the county in the later period, so Ms.Wagner’s auditors checked back until the initiation of the tax and found the company owes additional money. Ms. Wagner called the $1.44 million a “conservative” estimate that could actually be higher.
The car rental tax is earmarked for transit, and Ms. Wagner urged Allegheny County Council to require the unexpected $2.1 million to be used to restore Port Authority routes, including one to Baldwin, where the advocacy group Save Our Transit has been lobbying for several years for a return of the service. She called using the money in that way “a win-win for everyone.”
But Amie Downs, a spokeswoman for Allegheny County Executive Rich Fitzgerald, said it would be “unprecedented and shortsighted” to put that kind of restriction on the money since the agency has other needs, too.
Port Authority spokesman Jim Ritchie also pointed out that the county’s required subsidy for the agency is expected to increase by about $1 million next year from $28.8 million, allowing Port Authority to receive an additional $9 million in state funds under the state transportation bill approved last fall. He added that the agency annually reviews whether it should expand service based on customer need and equity, considering whether service would be more of a necessity in a low-income area.
Read More
Another factor is whether the service is financially sustainable, an open question in this case since the Hertz money is a one-time supplement.
Hertz has been paying the correct amount to the county since July 2011, when it discovered an “administrative error” in remitting the tax to the state instead of the county.
Spokesman Richard Broome said Thursday the company is “aware” of the county’s additional claim for back taxes but had no further comment.
Mr. Broome said Hertz is challenging whether it should pay penalties and interest since it wasn’t refusing to pay the taxes but paying them to the wrong place. Michael McCabe, solicitor for Allegheny County Treasurer John Weinstein, said a taxpayer is entitled to an administrative hearing with that office if it disputes any charge, but he declined to say whether Hertz is appealing.




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.