For more than a year, car rental giant Hertz collected the $2-a-day car rental tax but sent half of it to the state of Pennsylvania instead of Allegheny County.
Due to an “administrative oversight,” Hertz sent part of the fee it should have paid at its Pittsburgh International Airport location, $435,577, to the state as sales tax, Hertz said in its response to an audit by the county controller’s office released Tuesday. Controller Chelsa Wagner outlined the shortfall last month.
“There was not any willful intent to not remit the funds,” Hertz audit manager Tiffany Bell wrote. “We made good faith efforts to comply with the law, and collect and remit to the county. The problem was corrected and tax is being properly remitted.”
The underpayment occurred from May 2010 to June 2011, Ms. Wagner has said. Penalty fees totaling $205,020 and another $102,510 in interest bring the sum Hertz owes to $743,107, according to the county treasurer’s office.
On Tuesday, Robert Miecznikowski, manager of the treasurer’s special tax division, mailed a letter asking that Hertz pay that amount within 10 days or request a hearing on the matter. The company in its initial response to Ms. Wagner’s audit agreed that the car rental tax was underpaid to the county, but requested an “abatement” of penalties since the mistake wasn’t intentional.
Treasurer John Weinstein said he wants the full amount, penalties included.
Read More
Deputy county controller Amy Griser said Hertz would have the ability to seek a refund from the state, but whether the company has asked for one is unclear. A company spokeswoman said officials “continue to work with the county to get this matter resolved” but declined further comment.
A state revenue office spokeswoman said any interaction between that department and an independent taxpayer is confidential.
During the period in question, the amount the company paid to the county was about half of what it owed, according to the controller’s office. In June 2010, for example, Hertz paid $32,564 instead of $65,128.
How did more than a year of underpayment go unnoticed? The treasurer’s office has said amounts can vary month by month for self-reporting agencies like Hertz.
“There’s a lot of inconsistencies, especially in the rental car business,” Mr. Weinstein said. Several factors can contribute to a change, he said, and usage can spike in summer months and even during Steelers playoff season. “You really don’t know what they’re selling out there. A lot of it has to do with airport traffic and travel.”
The controller’s office found that Hertz also did not properly report gross revenue from two accounts to the Allegheny County Airport Authority — the agency it pays for space at the airport — from May 1, 2010, to April 20, 2013. With available credits, the company owed $17,153, which it agreed to pay in its response.
Since 2008, rental car companies have been required to collect a $2 tax for each rented vehicle per day, a sum remitted to the county treasurer’s office each month.
Ms. Wagner began auditing car rental companies at the airport in 2012 and is the first controller to do so.
Her office plans to expand an audit of Hertz’s airport submissions back to 2008 sometime early this year, Ms. Griser said. Independent auditors planned to check other Hertz locations in the county, the treasurer’s office has said.
Once paid, the money will be deposited as revenue in the county’s transit fund to pay its subsidy to Port Authority, and county council will decide how it will be used. Revenue from taxes on rental cars and alcoholic beverages — enacted the same year — was budgeted to hit $41.5 million last year.


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.