With battle lines between dinner and discounts firmly drawn this Thanksgiving, it seemed at the start of the day Thursday in Robinson as if dinner would come out ahead.

Long-standing family traditions of Thanksgiving feasts followed by Black Friday bargain hunts began to unravel last year, with retailers such as Wal-Mart, Best Buy and Toys R Us announcing they would open doors as early as 5 p.m. Ross Park Mall and The Mall at Robinson followed suit with 8 p.m. Thanksgiving openings that have crept even earlier into the holiday this year, with both malls open from 6 p.m. Thanksgiving through 9 p.m. today.

Aligning sales with the holiday turned out to be a mixed bag for the nation’s retailers last year. Although 44.8 million went shopping Thanksgiving Day and 92.1 million made their way to Black Friday sales, average spending of $407 per person was a 4 percent drop from 2012, according to the National Retail Federation.

The lukewarm reception to Thanksgiving sales may have carried over into this year. Although early-morning crowds made their way to a Robinson Kmart, which began selling steeply discounted Samsung Galaxy Tab 4 tablets for $149.99 at 6 a.m., the usual suspects waiting for Black Friday deals had yet to arrive at Best Buy and Target by 10 a.m.

Advertise with us

“Normally people would be here by now,” said Tony Shuttleworth of Carrick, who had been sitting in a folding chair behind Best Buy’s partition since 5 a.m. A veteran Black Friday discount shopper who has been snagging half-price flat screens and power tools as door prizes for the Superior Forge and Steel Christmas party the past seven years, Mr. Shuttleworth said in years past the line was headed by groups who camped out at the store a full day before the store opened for doorbusters. This year, he led the pack.

Wrapped in four layers of clothing and sipping Pepsi from a thermos, Mr. Shuttleworth said he would probably miss out on Thanksgiving dinner but wasn’t suffering the loss.

“I don’t like turkey anyway,” he said.

Heather McCracken of McKees Rocks also found herself in the No. 1 slot about 6 a.m. behind Target’s partition.

By 7 a.m., when she saw there was no danger of anyone coming along to steal her place, she decided to hold the position from the warmth of her conveniently parked car. Three hours later, the only people who had arrived were amused Target employees.

Advertise with us

“The workers are making fun of me,” she said. “They called me the crazy lady sitting outside.”

With Thanksgiving dinner being prepped for her and her seven siblings, Ms. McCracken wasn’t denying the insanity of the situation. And although her sister was bringing dinner to the line about noon and her nephew would take over in line about 3 p.m., she said she wished retailers didn’t put deal seekers in that position.

“I think they’ve ruined Thanksgiving dinner for families; look where I am,” she said.

Lines had yet to form at Wal-Mart, which was advertising doorbuster deals for 6 p.m. and 8 p.m. on Thursday as well as 6 a.m. today. However, a crowd of shoppers who arrived before the big sale wove their way around discounted displays wrapped in cellophane or caution tape to grab last-minute dinner items rather than gifts.

For Olive Hinzman of Neville Island, who got into a brawl over a baby doll during Black Friday shopping a few years back at Wal-Mart, there’s more incentive than just the holiday to save shopping for another day.

“I wake up and come the next day and if that’s all that’s left, that’s all that’s left,” she said. “They usually still have everything anyway.”