Retailers still haven’t quite figured out the insecure 2014 U.S. consumer — will she be willing to buy, how much will he spend? — but early Black Friday weekend results fed into hopes that this year will be better than the last holiday season when bad weather and data breaches forced heavy discounting.

“The Thanksgiving openings clearly worked,” said Charlie O’Shea, a retail analyst for Moody’s. “There’s lots of traffic, lots of business being done.”

A stream of store and mall openings at 5 and 6 p.m. Thursday didn’t always create the made-for-TV lines traditionally part of the holiday shopping launch, but crowds did seem to build as deals on tablets and flat screens and more pulled people out of their homes.

Ross Park Mall manager Lisa Earl wouldn’t count out the possibility of an even earlier opening next year. “There have been a lot of people in the mall all night, and now it’s slammed,” she said shortly after midnight.

Advertise with us

The nation’s largest retailer, Wal-Mart, put out a statement about 2 a.m. Friday reporting more than 22 million customers had been through its stores Thursday. The National Retail Federation had predicted more than 140 million shoppers might go to the nation’s stores at some point between Thursday and Sunday.

IBM’s tracking analytics showed online purchases on Thanksgiving up 14.3 percent over the same period last year, while Friday’s online shopping as of 3 p.m. was up 8 percent over Black Friday 2013.

But there’s miles to go before the holiday season is over. “This is a marathon. This is clearly not a sprint,” Mr. O’Shea said.

Weather delays shoppers

For some shoppers, getting to the mall Friday was not a sprint but a slog.

Advertise with us

Vernon Baker of Greene County said he, his wife and daughter were caught in the wintry mix that hit the Pittsburgh area in the wee hours. “I didn’t get here too early,” he said as he rested on a coin-operated massage chair at the Mall at Robinson. “Didn’t make it till 6 o’clock this morning.”

Mr. Baker said the drive to Robinson from Mount Morris in Perry, Greene County, normally takes about an hour, but he was ensnared in the brief but dangerous snowfall and ice that disrupted much of the early morning Black Friday travel.

“You could hardly see to drive,” he said. “We were going 25 miles an hour on the interstate.”

Nationally, weather didn’t look like a major factor in disrupting holiday shopping — at least not yet.

‘Less hectic’ shopping

Advertise with us

Earlier openings at traditional shopping centers may have eased the load of customer traffic hitting all at the same time, even if they have changed who qualifies as an early bird.

By 9 a.m. Friday, Debbie Zabielski had about half of her desired Christmas presents in tow in the frigid parking lot. She, her daughter and a few friends had started six hours before at Target, where she was surprised to see the iPad Mini had not sold out.

She thought the crowds were more spread out. “There are less lines, and it’s less hectic,” she said. “I still got all the deals I was looking for.”

Shoppers who came out on Thanksgiving snapped up the snow globes that J.C. Penney traditionally gives away. “I’m so mad there were no snow globes,” Melissa Jordan, 36, of Port Vue said at the Monroeville store. “They should give some out at 5 p.m.” Thursday when the store opens “and some out at 6 a.m. [Friday] when I’m here.”

Regardless, Ms. Jordan was in a pretty good mood. She had started shopping at 3:30 a.m. Friday at Kohl’s and, unlike last year, there was plenty of parking and she was able to walk to a cash register with no line.

Advertise with us

She also had no complaints on the Black Friday deals, for which she paid $285 but saved $763, including the set of cooking pots for which she paid $29.99, saving $90.

Jeff Boarts, 28, of Apollo had gone to the Best Buy at 6:30 p.m. Thursday at the Pittsburgh Mills mall and was back at the company’s Monroeville store when it reopened at 8 a.m. Friday to return two movies — “Gravity” and “Return to the Planet of the Apes” — and two flash drives that he had purchased the night before.

“Those were good deals,” he said. “I just didn’t need them that bad.”

Kneading a break

Lynn Weaver of Shadyside and her family were so concerned about the early openings taking employees away from their families that they made a point of not entering the mall until it was officially Friday.

Advertise with us

“My daughter refused to come and make people work on Thanksgiving, so she said we’re not going until midnight,” Ms. Weaver said.

Kellie Whisner, 44, of Turtle Creek woke up at 7 a.m. Thursday. She spent the night working at Bath & Body Works at Monroeville Mall. “I just keep saying the same thing over and over again,” she said, and then she turned to a group of women entering the store and said, “Buy three, get three free.”

In Robinson, first-year massage therapy student Nicole Lang, along with classmates from Pittsburgh Technical Institute, worked 11 p.m. to 6 a.m. giving out free massages. They kneaded, chopped and reinvigorated at least 175 stressed-out mall shoppers with 10 minutes of tranquility.

One woman, in particular, was agitated at the mall’s crowds, she said. “I was like, ‘It’s OK, calm down, I’ll take good care of you.’ I gave her an extra-long massage, got her really relaxed, and she almost fell asleep.”

She would have been the fourth person who dozed on Ms. Lang during the night.

Advertise with us

A Downtown tradition

Lori Gloninger of Mars was among two dozen family members ranging in age from 9 to 55 who bundled up for the 20-degree wind chills to come Downtown on Friday morning to see the sights. “It’s tradition,” Ms. Gloninger said, warming up inside Starbucks in Market Square.

As usual, the group, which has been making the trek Downtown for some 20 years, planned to visit the PPG Place Wintergarden to see the gingerbread house displays.

They also planned to shop at the holiday market in Market Square and head over to the South Side for lunch, a bit of shopping and a movie.

The various family members offered some reasons why they avoid the malls: “too crowded,” “not fun” and “not as festive.”

Advertise with us

Across town at Macy’s, a fair number of shoppers were on the first floor at 11 a.m. but no lines were at the registers. Stepping away from the purse counter with a package in hand, Marcia Ferguson of Hopewell said she had been coming Downtown the day after Thanksgiving “before they started calling it Black Friday.”

Read more about deals in Pittsburgh area malls and check out Black Friday photos on our blog

Deborah M. Todd: dtodd@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1652. Twitter: @deborahtodd. Teresa Lindeman: tlindeman@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2018